Centre for IT & IP Law (CiTiP) of the KU Leuven Laura Drechsler, Assistant Professor at the , Belgium; Research Fellow at the State Archives of Belgium, Belgium; Lecturer at the Open Universiteit, The Netherlands
Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information
Laura Drechsler
Centre for IT & IP Law (CiTiP) of the KU Leuven Laura Drechsler, Assistant Professor at the , Belgium; Research Fellow at the State Archives of Belgium, Belgium; Lecturer at the Open Universiteit, The Netherlands
Japan is one of the handful of countries that has been found adequate for its personal data protection regime from the perspective of the European Union (EU), allowing personal data to be transferred from the EU to Japan without further constraints. 1 At the same time, however, Japan has concluded several international trade agreements, 2 including one with the United States of America (US), 3 that only allow for very limited restrictions on data flows, including flows involving personal data. 4 Therefore, Japanese data protection law is trying to bridge the two very differing approaches from the EU and the US. 5 The EU is mandated by its own Court of Justice (CJEU) to understand data transfers as a question of ensuring the continuity of the fundamental rights protection of its residents. 6 The US, on the other hand, views international data flows as being crucial for international trade and economic growth. 7 Japanese data protection law seems to have room for both, although as pointed out by a project of the Digital Free Trade Alliance, for example, there are indications of a conflict between its trade agreements and its adequacy commitments to the EU. 8
On 13 December 2022 the European Commission published a draft for a third arrangement for data transfers to the US – the Data Privacy Framework (DPF). In this Working Paper, we want to assess whether the draft DPF has a chance of succeeding before the Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU). To this end, we first explain and subsequently compare the provisions of the draft DPF with those of its predecessors, the Safe Harbor Agreement and the Privacy Shield. Our assessment will be holistic, it will consider all the provisions of the draft DPF in order to provide a clear picture of what rules are envisioned within the draft DPF and how these rules differ from earlier versions. In a second step, we will assess whether the draft DPF fulfils the legal requirements for data transfers of the CJEU, GDPR and the Charter for both its general rules and its safeguards for governmental access In our concluding remarks, we demonstrate that the draft DPF is not the leap forward one would expect after two invalidations by the CJEU. Key weaknesses include the provisions on governmental access, especially the question of effective legal remedies, but also the general provisions on ensuring the protection of personal data transferred (e.g. in terms of data subject rights and legal remedies).
1 January 2021 in European Data Protection Law Review