Significance: Early in the US COVID-19 epidemic, Americans spent substantially more time at home to reduce cases. Disentangling voluntary from policy-induced behavioral changes is critical for governments grappling with relaxing or renewing restrictions. We estimate the number of additional reported cases that would have been needed to elicit a voluntary behavioral response equivalent to the behavioral response to policy. A substantial share of the observed behavioral response was voluntary. Stay-at-home orders increased the time people spent at home by replacing voluntary actions that likely would have emerged as cases rose. Our analysis is an initial step in answering the critical policy question as to whether fast forwarding the response provides sufficient public health benefits to justify the mandates.