Introduction: The Broaden-and-Build Theory of positive emotions is one of the best known and applied theories in Positive Psychology. It argues that positive emotions initiate an upward movement by opening up the mind and broadening thoughts and thus represents a counter model to the vicious circle-models of clinical psychology. The number of studies directly testing this theory in all components is scarce, ambiguities in the model impede clear inference.Method: To draw a conclusive picture on within-model processes, we applied network modeling on the components of the theory across two studies (N1 = 312; N2 = 302).Results: In both studies, the positive relationship between positive emotions, resources and life outcomes is well-supported, yet the role of broadening, as an intermediary component within these is questioned.Discussion: As the broadening component consistently deviated from the model’s predictions and thus did not contribute to the model as expected in either study, the validity of the Broaden-and-Build Theory in its current conceptualization is challenged, and our results point to the need to reassess the role of broadening.
In order to contribute to the consolidation in the field ofPositive Psychology, we reinvestigated the factor structure of top 10 positive emotions of Barbara Fredrickson. Former research in experimental settings resulted in a three-cluster solution, which we tested withexploratoryandconfirmatorymethodology against different factor models. Within our non-experimental data (N= 312), statistical evidence is presented, advocating for a single factor model of the 10 positive emotions. Different possible reasons for the deviating results are discussed, as well as the theoretical significance to various subfields inPositive Psychology(e.g., therapeutical interventions). Furthermore, the special role ofawewithin the study and its implications for further research in the field are discussed.
Introduction: The role of dispositional gratitude as a positive psychological resource and prosocial personality trait in real life interactions militates in favor of its introduction to the research field of social media.Methods: Based on a literature review of the previously studied relationship of dispositional gratitude with social comparison and envy in offline settings, a twofold moderation model was proposed and quantitatively tested in a cross-sectional sample of N = 268 Instagram users aged between 18 and 40 years. Additionally, the dual conceptualization of benign and malicious envy was scrutinized by validating its respective connections with affective outcomes and inspiration on Instagram.Results and discussion: Dispositional gratitude serves as a protective factor when using Instagram by significantly mitigating the relationship of social comparison and malicious as well as general envy on Instagram. Furthermore, the results support the more nuanced understanding of envy as a dual construct in the face of social media use.
11 August 2025 in The British Journal of Psychiatry
Background: Core premenstrual disorders (PMDs), including premenstrual syndrome (PMS) and premenstrual dysphoric disorder, can cause significant impairment. Despite evidence linking stress and premenstrual symptoms, a systematic synthesis is lacking. Aims: To systematically review the literature and meta-analyse evidence on the relationship between premenstrual symptoms and stress. Method: Four databases (Web of Science, PubMed, PsycINFO, Scopus) and Google Scholar were searched for studies indexed before 27 August 2024 (no language/year restrictions) assessing the relationship between self-reported stress and premenstrual symptoms in regularly menstruating individuals (PROSPERO: CRD42021244503). Three multilevel meta-analyses estimated (a) the correlation between stress and premenstrual symptom severity, (b) stress differences between individuals with and without core PMD across the menstrual cycle and (c) the impact of traumatic experiences on the occurrence of premenstrual symptoms. Study quality and publication bias were assessed. Results: We synthesised 188 effect sizes from 66 studies (N = 38 344), indicating (a) a positive correlation (r = 0.29, 95% CI 0.23–0.36); (b) higher stress levels in participants with core PMD (d = 0.79, 95% CI 0.32–1.26), particularly during the luteal phase (dlut = 1.01, 95% CI 0.46–1.57); and (c) over twofold higher odds (odds ratio 2.45, 95% CI 1.87–3.23) of PMS in individuals with a history of trauma. Heterogeneity was high (I2 = 84.64–91.38%); one meta-analysis (c) showed evidence of publication bias. Conclusions: The results indicate an association between stress and premenstrual symptoms, an effect of cycle phase and trauma as a risk factor for PMS. Future research should explore underlying biopsychosocial mechanisms.
Obesity is one of the most widespread public health risks, with more than 1 billion affected individuals worldwide. While treatment with ‘anti-obesity’ medication (GLP-1 agonists) shows promising results, patients face public backlash for ‘cutting corners’. Across four pre-registered within-subject studies in three countries (N = 1.205, Belgium, US, UK), we found that users of GLP-1 medication are perceived as less moral, presumably because they are thought to have exerted less effort in their weight-loss endeavor. Further, we observed effects on broader consequences (e.g., competence or deservingness perceptions) and tested candidate moderators (e.g., attitudes, experience, personality). Our findings highlight the adverse consequences of effort-based biases experienced by patients using anti-obesity medication and underscore the need for public education and stigma reduction.
Inferring moral character of individuals is an adaptive need for social decision-making. The effort moralization effect describes the finding that people who exert more effort in a task are seen as more moral, even if higher effort does lead to higher outcomes (e.g., higher performance or better quality). We replicated this effect, based on Celniker et al. (2023, Study 6), in countries not yet investigated (Germany and Mexico). Further, drawing on discussions around workforce participation (see ‘great resignation’ or ‘quiet quitting’) criticizing the lower work ethic of younger individuals (e.g., the so-called Gen Z), we tested whether (ineffective) effort is moralized less in younger individuals. Our findings support the generalizability of effort moralization to Germany and Mexico, yet point to heterogeneity in effect strength. However, our findings do not support the hypothesis that effort moralization increases with age. This indicates that young people do not see effort as less valuable than older people. We discuss further implications and limitations of these findings and suggest avenues for future research on effort moralization.