This review presents theoretical underpinnings supporting microethnographic-discourse analytic (ME/DA) approaches to studying educational phenomena. The review is presented in two parts. Part 1 provides an analytic review of two seminal reviews of literature that frame theoretical and methodological developments of microethnography and functions language in classrooms with diverse learners. Part 2 presents two telling case studies that illustrate the logic-of-inquiry of (ME/DA) approaches. These telling case studies make transparent how theoretical considerations of cultural perspectives on education inform decisions regarding research methodology. Telling Case Study 1 makes transparent the logic-of-inquiry undertaken to illustrate how microanalyses of discourse and action among participants in a physics class provided an empirical grounding for identifying how different groups undertook a common task. This case study shows how ethnographically informed discourse analyses formed a foundation to theoretically identify social processes of knowledge construction. Telling Case Study 2 makes transparent multiple levels of analysis undertaken to examine ways that creative processes of interpretation of art were communicated and taken up in an art studio class across multiple cycles of activity. Taken together, these telling case studies provide evidence of how ME/DA provides a theoretically grounded logic-of-inquiry for investigating complex learning processes in different educational contexts.
Reflexivity involves examining one’s background and perspectives in relation to the research topic, participants, and the processes and practices of research. Building on the growing field of utilizing arts-based practices in teaching qualitative research, in this article we examine how one doctoral student’s engagement with drawing and painting within and beyond a qualitative research class supported her developing reflexivity. Guided by an interactional ethnographic perspective, we conducted domain, taxonomic, and discourse analyses of the student’s art, reflection journals, video of a class presentation, and retrospective reflections she wrote three years later. Through these analyses we make visible that reflexivity through art creates potentials for understanding and transcending one’s background to create new opportunities for learning about self and research. We also argue that deepening reflexivity requires a commitment to engage in the discomforts of learning in order to develop new ways of thinking and researching.
The gender gap among patent holders in the U.S. has been well documented. Some studies illuminating the need for greater diversity have included recommendations for new policies aimed at changing the differential ways men and women take up opportunities to develop as inventors and to obtain U.S. patents. However, limited studies are available to guide the design of programs and establishment of policies that reflect promising practices for teaching young women to invent and patent during their high school years. This article reports findings from the study of the Lemelson-MIT Program's 14-year-old high school InvenTeams initiative and related policy implications for increasing gender diversity among U.S. patent holders through invention education in high school. The initiative has engaged more than 2,200 high school students (34% female) in inventing, with seven of the 229 teams obtaining U.S. patents. The program's records, student surveys, and participant interviews serve as a foundation for the study. Our analyses of the interview transcripts examined what supported and constrained three young women's participation in the year-long, team-based invention process and how the InvenTeam experience influenced their ways of seeing themselves as leaders, inventors, and innovators. Factors that supported their work as inventors included the organization and processes of InvenTeams, various resources and people, and their own personal qualities, values, and beliefs. Factors that constrained their work included time, stereotypes, and lack of prior knowledge, exposure, understanding, and engagement.
This response to Slavin’s article (2008) explores the issues of transparency, representation, and warranting of claims in Slavin’s descriptions of the work of others and his suggestions for program evaluation syntheses. Through contrastive analyses between Slavin’s representations of the program evaluation synthesis efforts of five organizations and their own representations of their synthesis work, the authors uncover the ways in which the gaps in Slavin’s text become consequential for readers, limiting readers’ opportunities for developing understandings of synthesis efforts. Through contrastive analyses, the authors foreground the need for transparency in reporting, raise questions about the use of narrowly focused reviews, and demonstrate how a contrastive analysis of texts may constitute a productive approach to critical reading and an opportunity for learning.