What can government do to secure environmental sustainability and resilient communities? We discuss an emerging policy approach in natural tourism resource management in the Okinawa Prefecture using the case of the ‘Conservation and Use Agreement’ (CUA, hereafter) defined in the Act on Special Measures for the Promotion of Okinawa. The CUA is the certification by the Governor of Okinawa Prefecture, which endorses the self-regulation concluded by site-level eco-tour operators. We analysed the legal and administrative structure of the CUA and the implementation process of nine (existing/expired) CUA cases based on thorough literature reviews and in-depth interviews. We discuss three points from the analysis. Firstly, the number of CUAs remains small because of its huge transaction costs compared to the benefits of the status. Secondly, the CUA generally works as a precaution; however, it is not effective for solving the existing overuse issues for its voluntary characteristics. Thirdly, the administrative resources need to be strengthened for better communication with operators to further enhance the implementation.
This study examines the process and outcome of institutional change from a self-governing common-pool resources (CPR) model into state-reinforced self-governance. Empirical evidence is drawn from the Philippines’ experience in decentralizing the management of communal irrigation systems (CIS) to local farmers through Irrigators Associations (IAs). The field data were collected through archival research, a review of secondary documents, and key informant interviews in Sagada, Philippines. Through institutional analysis, the study confirms earlier empirical findings that self-governing bodies can work well with the state provided they do not impinge on the autonomy of resource users. However, user expectations regarding the costs and benefits of state-reinforced self-governance affect its likelihood of success. Drawing from the case study, changes in the value and distribution of transaction costs are the two biggest challenges to sustaining state-reinforced IAs. The first challenge is the introduction of membership and irrigation fees, a huge shift from the non-monetary contribution that farmers were accustomed to. The second challenge is the change in the allocation and distribution of transaction costs or, simply, who bears what cost. Further research is recommended to expand the current discourse on state-reinforced self-governance to include more in-depth transaction cost analysis.
The Western Nghe An Biosphere Reserve, recognized by UNESCO, presents both ecological significance and socio-economic potential. This study evaluated the local community's capacity for sustainable development within the biosphere reserve and identified critical capacities required for long-term success in conservation and socio-economic integration. We employed quantitative surveys and exploratory factor analysis to determine key factors influencing these capacities, uncovering essential areas for targeted interventions. A survey was conducted with 500 residents of the Western Nghe An Biosphere Reserve. This study found that while several key capacities related to sustainable development were well-developed among community members, significant gaps in environmental awareness and community engagement hindered broader participation in sustainable initiatives, such as capacity-building programs on training local communities in village-based and eco-tourism. These findings highlight the need for enhanced community awareness and skill-building programs, particularly in environmental consciousness, resource management, and community collaboration. The study proposes solutions to strengthen capacities aligned with the Lima Action Plan for UNESCO’s Man and the Biosphere (MAB) Programme and its World Network of Biosphere Reserves, which could contribute to achieving national sustainable development goals.