Current literature on mindfulness offers inadequate distinction between neo-traditional mindfulness and cognitive behavioral mindfulness, to the extent that both approaches can be included within the same meta-analyses. A close examination of the mechanisms of action in several forms of mindfulness using a lens of Gurdjieffian phenomenology of awareness can point toward a clear and well defined distinction between varieties of mindfulness. The phenomenology of cognitive behavioral mindfulness suggests that it involves an enhanced attention to the cognitive contents of awareness, as in Gurdjieff’s second state, but give no evidence of attaining self-reflexive awareness in which attention attunes to its own presence as the context of cognitive processes. Neo-traditional and meditative forms of mindfulness are more likely to attend to both the contents and the context of consciousness, a change associated with a shift in state of consciousness. Using Gurdjieff’s phenomenology of awareness, neo-traditional mindfulness can be seen as similar to Gurdjieff’s self-remembering, in which awareness attends to the cognitive contents of experience as well as to its own presence. Cognitive behavioral versions of mindfulness differ from both of these in that the object of attention does not extend self-reflexively beyond cognitive contents.
Objectives Objective assessment of mindfulness requires increased precision in defining associated cognitive processes. Previous work argued that vipaśyanā-like mindfulness can be characterized as a specific attentional stance—how the felt sense of self is located relative to the body. We therefore studied effect of specific shifts in attentional stance on stress reduction, mindfulness, and interoceptive awareness indices in meditation novices and Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) practitioners. Method This paper reports on three separate studies using a simple pre-test post-test design with meditation novices and MBSR practitioners, all of whom received brief instruction (≤1 hr) in an attentional stance expected to induce vipaśyanā-like mindfulness. Novices and MBSR practitioners then participated with a 10-min recorded version of the attentional stance exercise (ASE) and were assessed on measures of perceived stress and mindfulness. MBSR practitioners were similarly assessed after a 10-min MBSR practice. One group of novices was also assessed on measures of interoceptive awareness and three positive emotions. Results In novices, the 10-min ASE resulted in reductions in significant stress indices and increases in mindfulness and interoceptive awareness indices. In MBSR practitioners, the ASE and MBSR practices produced similar results in stress and mindfulness. In MBSR practitioners, attentional stance in the abdomen was associated with a modestly greater, and marginally significant, increase in mindfulness than that in the chest. Conclusions Brief training and a short practice session entering a diffuse abdominal attentional stance yield stress reduction and increases in mindfulness similar to the impact of an MBSR meditation practice used by trained MBSR practitioners. Attentional stance is associated with specific biologically linked and cognitively relevant somatic markers, making it an effective behavioral instrument for obtaining objective data and mechanism assessment in vipaśyanā-like mindfulness.