24 December 2024 in International Journal of Gender and Entrepreneurship
Purpose: This paper explores the ways women entrepreneurs in male-dominated industries do identity work in order to gain legitimacy. In particular, we consider such identity work as a process being prompted by their direct environment, while demonstrating the gendered structural power relations in these women’s entrepreneurial contexts. We use a postfeminist lens to show how, in their quest for more legitimacy, they seem to be interpellated by postfeminist discourse.Design/methodology/approach: We have used a narrative approach to show how women entrepreneurs in masculinised contexts do identity work to acquire legitimacy, and moreover use a postfeminist perspective to reflect on this identity work as to demonstrate how these Dutch businesswomen consider their agency in specific feminist terms within these men-dominated industry environments.Findings: We present empirical data of ten women entrepreneurs in the Netherlands and how they discursively and subjectively make sense of their surrounding gendered contexts, in order to illustrate how local gender regimes and individual actions may conspire to constrain as well as stimulate these women’s entrepreneurship. By reflecting on three different ways of identity work through a postfeminist lens, we show how these women are interpellated by postfeminist discourses when trying to gain legitimacy.Research limitations/implications: The rather small sample does not allow us to generalise our findings to the whole population of women entrepreneurs in men-dominated contexts, yet this was not our goal anyway.Practical implications: Such a reflection might help policy makers and such women themselves realise how, after all, gender inequality is still persistant in the entrepreneurship field and drawing on postfeminism does not necessarily help to support these women entrepreneurs' work–life balance.Social implications: Our findings underline the importance of a more gender inclusive entrepreneurship ecosystem, in which women entrepreneurs in both masculinised ánd feminised sectors are seen and treated as legitimate entrepreneurs.Originality/value: Postfeminism, to our knowledge, has hardly been applied to women entrepreneurs' experiences in men-dominated environments, and is in itself still a rather new field in entrepreneurship studies.
27 October 2021 in Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal
Purpose: In this contribution to EDI's professional insights, the authors develop practical and evidence-based recommendations that are developed for bias mitigation, discretion elimination and process optimization in panel evaluations and decisions in research funding. An analysis is made of how the expectation of “selling science” adds layers of complexity to the evaluation and decision process. The insights are relevant for optimization of similar processes, including publication, recruitment and selection, tenure and promotion.Design/methodology/approach: The recommendations are informed by experiences and evidence from commissioned projects with European research funding organizations. The authors distinguish between three aspects of the evaluation process: written applications, enacted performance and group dynamics. Vignettes are provided to set the stage for the analysis of how bias and (lack of) fit to an ideal image makes it easier for some than for others to be funded.Findings: In research funding decisions, (over)selling science is expected but creates shifting standards for evaluation, resulting in a narrow band of acceptable behavior for applicants. In the authors' recommendations, research funding organizations, evaluators and panel chairs will find practical ideas and levers for process optimization, standardization and customization, in terms of awareness, accountability, biased language, criteria, structure and time.Originality/value: Showing how “selling science” in research funding adds to the cumulative disadvantage of bias, the authors offer design specifications for interventions to mitigate the negative effects of bias on evaluations and decisions, improve selection habits, eliminate discretion and create a more inclusive process.
4 November 2025 in Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal
Purpose: This professional insight contribution introduces equine-assisted learning (EAL) to the field of equality, diversity and inclusion (EDI) in organizations. As a form of experiential learning (Clark et al., 2024; Stock and Kolb, 2016), EAL answers the call for more practical rather than cognitive forms of EDI interventions in organizations by offering participants instant opportunities to experience and practice with old and new behavior (Bilginoglu, 2021; Meola, 2016). Relating participants' EAL experiences to theoretical EDI knowledge, this contribution provides the ground to initiate a conversation about considering EAL as an additional element to our current EDI work, both in theory and in practice. Design/methodology/approach: Inspired by observations working as EAL facilitator and EDI scholar and practitioner, I analyzed fragments of participants' reflections based on EAL experiences using alterity as a sensitizing concept. As a means to create a space without judgment in which people can encounter each other free of normalized thoughts and structures, alterity as a concept enhances our understanding how to increase diversity and inclusion (Ghorashi and Sabelis, 2013; Janssens and Steyaert, 2001). Organized along the lines of the three conditions and three tactics theoretically qualifying alterity (Janssens and Steyaert, 2001), the analysis explores elements of EAL reflections in light of such conditions and tactics. Findings: Illustrating congruencies between EAL and alterity, this contribution provides initial insights on how EAL may help to bring alterity into practice. Showing that EAL bears elements of alterity and relying on previous studies showing that EAL experiences translate well to other (work) environments, the findings of the analysis provide a first stepping stone to consider EAL as a means to help translate alterity into practice. As such, the findings also suggest that it may be worthwhile to further explore EAL in (organizational) EDI contexts. Originality/value: Introducing EAL to the EDI context offers opportunities to challenge our view on our current EDI work, both in theory and practice. Further practicing and studying, while starting and continuing conversations on EAL or other forms of experiential learning, may provide new ways of supporting EDI in organizations.