This paper investigates how actors across spatial levels shape the directions of transition. We examine two Chinese provinces, Inner Mongolia and Jiangsu, with contrasting directionalities of solar photovoltaic (PV) development. The former developed PV as part of the large-scale centralized power system, and the latter focused on PV development as a core element of an alternative distributed form of power generation. We argue that three aspects have been key for understanding the divergent patterns: the specific portfolio of enacted institutional work; the type of interactions between niche and regime actors; and the selective leveraging of national institutional conditions by provincial actors.
23 December 2021 in Frontiers in Research Metrics and Analytics
Basic research is believed to be a crucial factor for building national innovation capacity and therefore was perceived as a key battleground for national technological and economic competition. Since the economic reform and opening up in the late 1970s, China has made great achievements in building up its national research system. However, the lacking capabilities to conduct ground-breaking scientific work remain one of the daunting challenges for the country. How to restructure its funding system for basic research so to reinvigorate its indigenous innovation capacity has been one of the main concerns for the Chinese government in recent years. To address this, the paper proposes a conceptual framework to analyze how China’s central government funding system for basic research has evolved since 1985. The paper concludes with a discussion of the identified problems and challenges that China is facing in its current funding system for basic research.
27 September 2025 in Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions
A limited set of studies have addressed how actors shape the directionality of sustainability transitions. Building on recent institutional work literature, this article explores how specific institutional activities developed by both niche and regime actors across spatial levels shape the directions of transition. We examine two cases with contrasting directionalities: solar PV in the provinces of Inner Mongolia and Jiangsu, both located in China. The former developed PV as part of the large-scale centralised power system and the latter focused on PV development as a core element of an alternative distributed form of power generation. We investigate provincial differences as well as the state-provincial dynamics. The article therefore develops a multi-scalar understanding of institutional work. Our research findings suggest three aspects have been key for understanding the divergent patterns: the specific portfolios of enacted institutional work, the type of interactions between niche and regime actors and the selective leveraging of institutional conditions at national by provincial actors. Based on these findings we formulate four propositions and propose a novel conceptual framework to investigate how actors shape the directionality of sustainability transition.
Acceleration has multiple implicit meanings in the emerging literatures on sustainability transitions, systems transformation, and science and technology studies, among other disciplines. But how has acceleration been conceptualised in social sciences literatures analysing transitions towards sustainability? Are there potential synergies across these literatures that can advance our understanding of acceleration? In this paper we take stock of existing knowledge and propose a new conceptual understanding of this increasingly crucial phenomenon based on a systematic and critical literature review consisting of 171 published studies. In doing so, we both map the field and critically interrogate its contributions. The review harnesses insights from both the socio-technical system transitions and broader social science literatures to capture how the different disciplines research the acceleration of transitions towards sustainability. We classify different perspectives that envision acceleration as a phenomenon, a purpose, a process, and a multi-faceted concept. We conclude by presenting a novel conceptual typology of acceleration for sustainability transitions.
1. While both scholars and policy practitioners increasingly recognise the importance of place-based approaches in transformative innovation policy (Schwaag-Serger et al., 2023), the conceptual and...