Given the challenging transition from secondary school into higher education, this quasi-experimental study measured the effects of a pre-academic programme (i.e. before starting at university) on student–faculty interactions, student–peer interactions, sense of belonging, and first-year academic performance. Fifty-eight first-year students participated in a pre-academic programme (i.e. the experimental group) focused on changing their perceptions of effective learning behaviour to enhance high-quality interaction with peers and faculty, their sense of belonging, and academic performance. A control group comprised 237 first-year students who did not attend the programme. Participation in the programme enhanced formal student–faculty and student-peer interactions, as well as informal student-peer interactions. No effect was found on sense of belonging. Furthermore, participation in the programme enhanced students’ attained grade during the first course and enhanced their first-year cumulative GPA. The results suggest that participation in the pre-academic programme could give students a head start in higher education.
17 February 2017 in Educational Research and Evaluation
Given the large number of dropouts in the 1st year at university, it is important to identify early predictors of 1st-year academic success. The present study (n = 453 first-year students) contributes to literature on the transition from secondary to higher education by investigating how the non-cognitive factors pre-university effort and pre-university academic self-efficacy influence 1st-year retention at university. In addition, we examined pre-university reasons for attending university and whether these reasons were related to 1st-year retention. Multinomial logistic regression analyses showed that pre-university effort positively predicted 1st-year retention, whereas pre-university academic self-efficacy did not. With exploratory factor analysis and confirmatory factor analysis, we identified six pre-university reasons for attending university: career perspective, personal development, compliance with the social environment, attractiveness of the institution, recommended by others, and location. None of the pre-university reasons appeared to significantly predict 1st-year retention. Implications for research and practice are discussed.
2 October 2024 in European Journal of Higher Education
Self-selection refers to the decision of qualified students to not pursue their highest possible educational degree, including higher education. In this systematic meta-review, we used the conceptual framework of college choice to identify resources or mechanisms for students’ self-selection from higher education in international reviews and meta-analyses. In addition, we investigate whether underrepresented student groups (i.e., first-generation and cultural minority) experience unique resources and mechanisms for self-selection. Our narrative synthesis of international reviews and meta-analyses indicated that self-selection is related to financial, informational, social, aspirational resources in all contextual layers (i.e. individual habitus, school and community, higher education, socio-political context) of the conceptual framework of college choice. Whereas the family can help prevent self-selection by providing all four types of resources, school and higher education institutions can provide important information and social support through counselling and mentoring activities. For underrepresented groups, vertical and horizontal transmissions of social capital and experienced personal fit with the higher education environment may be of special importance for preventing self-selection. We conclude by discussing the potential of self-selection as concept for future interventions and research on widening access to higher education.
Many higher education institutions organize summer bridge programs (SBPs) to prepare students for university. However, what a SBP should contain is unclear because few studies directly compare different theoretical approaches. This study evaluated two types of SBPs offered at a Dutch university: (A) a sociological approach focusing on academic capital and (B) a psychological approach targeting mindset and metacognition. We randomly assigned 250 applicants between these programs. Participants in both programs were compared with each other and with (C) 161 students who neither applied for nor attended any SBP. We hypothesized that A would improve students’ academic capital, while B would improve students’ mindset and metacognition. As hypothesized, Program A improved students’ scores on two aspects of academic capital formation: navigation of systems and trustworthy information. Unexpectedly, Program B produced similar improvements. As predicted, Program B enhanced students’ metacognition and mindset scores, with these participants outperforming both other conditions at posttest. Unexpectedly, Program A increased the growth mindset and effort beliefs of first-generation students, while it decreased scores for these outcomes for continuous-generation students. We found no significant differences in academic performance between groups, suggesting that brief SBPs may be insufficient to generate medium effects on longer term outcomes. Qualitative data revealed that while some students retained and applied specific SBP content, most prioritized familiarization with peers and the university environment over program curriculum.
Many higher education institutions organize summer bridge programs (SBPs) to prepare students for university. However, the effectiveness of SBPs is unclear, because randomized trials and comparisons between different approaches are lacking. This study evaluated the impact of two types of SBP offered at a Dutch university: (A) sociological, focusing on academic capital, and (B) psychological, targeting mindset and metacognition, with 250 SBP applicants randomly assigned to these two programs. They were compared with each other and with (C) 161 students who did not attend any SBP. We hypothesized that A would improve students’ academic capital, while B would improve students’ mindset and metacognition. Students in both programs were hypothesized to outperform students in C. Results showed increased scores for students in Programs A (as hypothesized) and B (not hypothesized) for two aspects of academic capital formation: navigation of systems and trustworthy information. As predicted, students in Program B increased their scores for metacognition and mindset, and scored higher for these on the posttest compared to both other conditions. Unexpectedly, Program A increased growth mindset and effort beliefs of first-generation students, while it decreased scores for these outcomes for continuous-generation students. We found no significant differences between the groups for academic performance; an SBP might be too brief to generate medium effects on longer term outcomes. Qualitative data showed that some students remembered and applied specific content from the SBPs, but that for most students the SBP content was secondary to familiarization with peers and the university environment ahead of time.