The article is a discussion of the concept of power in three different social theories that are often applied to educational research: the theories of Jürgen Habermas, Pierre Bourdieu, and Michel Foucault. In everyday life, the concept of power is used as if it only had a single connotation: power as possessed by someone (“the powerful”) while exercised over someone else (“the powerless”). In this case, power is considered as a (potentially) repressive force and ascribed to a person, a culture, a state, or a society. Though, power can be comprehended otherwise: as non-possessed and productive. In the paper, the three conceptions of power are presented and discussed in relation to each other and to specific philosophical themes like dualism, reductionism, determinism and autonomy, truth, normativity, and relativism. Finally, the paper shows that the applied power-concept has significant consequences for the way the educational researcher analyzes conflicts, and therefore also for our understanding of the world in which we live.
2 January 2015 in International Journal of Multiple Research Approaches
The aim of this paper is to discuss how Michel Foucault's concept of power can contribute to the discussion of research ethics in qualitative interviewing within the field of social psychology. Minimizing power is a common aim in the ethical principles of psychology and in research interviewing. Using examples from my own research, I show that the traditional concept of power seems insufficient to capture what is at stake in group interview situations. The group interview adds a group dynamic, making it significantly more complicated than the individual interview. To account for this complexity, this paper suggests elaborating the discussion of ethics in the research interview through Foucault's concept of power as a productive force.
4 April 2016 in International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education
The aim of this paper was to demonstrate how genealogy can be used as a method for critical education research. As Foucault emphasized, genealogy is a method for identifying the way in which the individuals are subjectified through discourse. The genealogical analysis in the article defines two mayor tendencies in contemporary Danish pedagogy: individualization and structuralizing. The analyses also show an example of how the two tendencies are intermingled in the Danish law of learning plans in day care institutions.
The aim of this paper is to demonstrate how poststructuralism and social constructionism can contribute to the empirical research on groups in problem-based learning (PBL). The paper outlines the analytical complexity and shows, through empirical examples, the potentials and limitations of this perspective as an alternative to traditional group psychology. While the potentials of poststructuralism and social constructionism as an analytical complex seem to be the endeavor for relentless critique, the limitations are the ‘empty subject’ and the avoidance of any kind of normativity that leave no guidance for practice. Though both limitations raise serious problems for the practitioner, I intend to argue that the potentials of the analytical perspective are far more important than the challenges when it comes to social psychological research in groups in PBL.
29 March 2016 in Nordic Journal of Social Research
Artiklen giver et indblik i gruppers rolle og funktion i pædagogikken, sådan som det har formet sig i Danmark. Dette sker igennem en genealogisk analyse inspireret af den franske filosof Michel Foucault. Det betyder, at der er fokus på de måder, hvorpå individer subjektiveres, dvs., hvordan de kan blive til subjekter. I artiklen vises det, hvordan grupper har været brugt i pædagogikken fra 1800-tallets indbyrdes undervisning, i den tidlige reformpædagogik fra starten af 1900-tallet, i projektpædagogikken, der havde sin oprindelse i 1970’erne, samt i den nutidige Cooperative Learning. I analysen vises det, hvordan de forskellige tilgange rummer meget forskellige subjektiveringstilbud for såvel elever som lærere: fra underkastelse og disciplin i den indbyrdes undervisning til individualisering i den tidlige reformpædagogik, fleksibilitet og kritisk stillingtagen i projektpædagogikken til internalisering af struktur i CL.