Following Toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) stimulation of macrophages, negative feedback mediated by the anti-inflammatory cytokine interleukin-10 (IL-10) limits the inflammatory response. However, extensive cell-to-cell variability in TLR4-stimulated cytokine secretion raises questions about how negative feedback is robustly implemented. To explore this, we characterize the TLR4-stimulated secretion program in primary murine macrophages using a single-cell microwell assay that enables evaluation of functional autocrine IL-10 signaling. High-dimensional analysis of single-cell data reveals three tiers of TLR4-induced proinflammatory activation based on levels of cytokine secretion. Surprisingly, while IL-10 inhibits TLR4-induced activation in the highest tier, it also contributes to the TLR4-induced activation threshold by regulating which cells transition from non-secreting to secreting states. This role for IL-10 in restraining TLR4 inflammatory activation is largely mediated by intermediate interferon (IFN)-β signaling, while TNF likely mediates response resolution by IL-10. Thus, cell-to-cell variability in cytokine regulatory motifs provides a means to tailor the TLR4-induced inflammatory response.
Checkpoint inhibitors have revolutionized cancer treatment, but resistance remains a significant clinical challenge. Myeloid cells within the tumor microenvironment can modulate checkpoint resistance by either supporting or suppressing adaptive immune responses. Using an anti–PD-1–resistant mouse melanoma model, we show that targeting the myeloid compartment via CD40 activation and CSF1R blockade in combination with anti–PD-1 results in complete tumor regression in a majority of mice. This triple therapy combination was primarily CD40 agonist-driven in the first 24 hours after therapy and showed a similar systemic cytokine profile in human patients as was seen in mice. Functional single-cell cytokine secretion profiling of dendritic cells (DC) using a novel microwell assay identified a CCL22+CCL5+ IL12-secreting DC subset as important early-stage effectors of triple therapy. CD4+ and CD8+ T cells are both critical effectors of treatment, and systems analysis of single-cell RNA sequencing data supported a role for DC-secreted IL12 in priming T-cell activation and recruitment. Finally, we showed that treatment with a novel IL12 mRNA therapeutic alone was sufficient to overcome PD-1 resistance and cause tumor regression. Overall, we conclude that combining myeloid-based innate immune activation and enhancement of adaptive immunity is a viable strategy to overcome anti–PD-1 resistance.
Macrophages and dendritic cells (DCs), although ontogenetically distinct, have overlapping functions and exhibit substantial cell-to-cell heterogeneity that can complicate their identification and obscure innate immune function. In this study, we report that M-CSF–differentiated murine bone marrow–derived macrophages (BMDMs) exhibit extreme heterogeneity in the production of IL-12, a key proinflammatory cytokine linking innate and adaptive immunity. A microwell secretion assay revealed that a small fraction of BMDMs stimulated with LPS secrete most IL-12p40, and we confirmed that this is due to extremely high expression of Il12b, the gene encoding IL-12p40, in a subset of cells. Using an Il12b-YFP reporter mouse, we isolated cells with high LPS-induced Il12b expression and found that this subset was enriched for genes associated with the DC lineage. Single-cell RNA sequencing data confirmed a DC-like subset that differentiates within BMDM cultures that is transcriptionally distinct but could not be isolated by surface marker expression. Although not readily apparent in the resting state, upon LPS stimulation, this subset exhibited a typical DC-associated activation program that is distinct from LPS-induced stochastic BMDM cell-to-cell heterogeneity. Overall, our findings underscore the difficulty in distinguishing macrophages and DCs even in widely used in vitro murine BMDM cultures and could affect the interpretation of some studies that use BMDMs to explore acute inflammatory responses.