2 July 2021 in Tourism Geographies
Community-based tourism (CBT) emphasises attributes such as sustainability, local participation, and the maximisation of benefits to the community. However, limited scholarly interventions and critical debates have been conducted regarding what constitutes a community in tourism destinations. In Taman Negara, Malaysia, residents of various ethnic groups have considerably different interpretations of community and boundaries therein. Malay, Malaysian Chinese, and Orang Asli Batek people have contradicting claims and perceptions regarding who is Indigenous, who is a local, and who is the rightful host community of Taman Negara. The perceptions of such boundaries can be highly political; consequently, certain groups feel threatened when they are seemingly peripheral to official designations. The fuzzy boundaries of what constitutes a community make governance and the assessment of CBT considerably challenging. A suggestion is to resist predefining a community and to instead consider its fluid boundaries and heterogeneity in CBT planning and research.
30 April 2026 in Tourist Studies
This paper advances a methodological argument for episodic tourism ethnography in multi-ethnic, politically sensitive field sites. Drawing from my fieldwork in Taman Negara, Malaysia, I explore how a tourism ethnographer moves across different communities and shifts between the tourist-facing and host-community arenas, all while managing insider-outsider roles. Within this broader reflection, the paper introduces “multi-layered shifting positionalities” as a heuristic for understanding how layered positionalities are organised through movement between two principal arenas in tourism ethnography, as well as the researcher’s shifting positionality across different communities. The paper shows how uneven immersion, boundary-conscious routeing, and retreat-and-return rhythms can become deliberate strategies for sustaining access, protecting relationships and interpreting inter-group tensions without being absorbed into any single group’s worldview. It also clarifies the ethical implications of such mobility, emphasising consent, role presentation, and long-term accountability. The paper advances tourism anthropology and critical qualitative methods by providing practical guidance for researchers in complex, plural and contested destinations.