1 June 2006 in Systematic Biology
Phylogenies based on gene content rely on statements of primary homology to characterize gene presence or absence. These statements (hypotheses) are usually determined by techniques based on threshold similarity or distance measurements between genes. This fundamental but problematic step can be examined by evaluating each homology hypothesis by the extent to which it is corroborated by the rest of the data. Here we test the effects of varying the stringency for making primary homology statements using a range of similarity (e-value) cutoffs in 166 fully sequenced and annotated genomes spanning the tree of life. By evaluating each resulting data set with tree-based measurements of character consistency and information content, we find a set of homology statements that optimizes overall corroborration. The resulting data set produces well-resolved and well-supported trees of life and greatly ameliorates previously noted inconsistencies such as the misclassification of small genomes. The method presented here, which can be used to test any technique for recognizing primary homology, provides an objective framework for evaluating phylogenetic hypotheses and data sets for the tree of life. It also can serve as a technique for identifying well-corroborated sets of homologous genes for functional genomic applications.
18 November 2008 in Acta Biotheoretica
We examine three critical aspects of Popper’s formulation of the ‘Logic of Scientific Discovery’—evidence, content and degree of corroboration—and place these concepts in the context of the Tree of Life (ToL) problem with particular reference to molecular systematics. Content, in the sense discussed by Popper, refers to the breadth and scope of existence that a hypothesis purports to explain. Content, in conjunction with the amount of available and relevant evidence, determines the testability, or potential degree of corroboration, of a statement; content distinguishes scientific hypotheses from metaphysical assertions. Degree of corroboration refers to the relative and tentative confidence assigned to one hypothesis over another, based upon the performance of each under critical tests. Here we suggest that systematists attempt to maximize content and evidence to increase the potential degree of corroboration in all phylogenetic endeavors. Discussion of this “total evidence” approach leads to several interesting conclusions about generating ToL hypotheses.