2 July 2019 in Journal of the American Statistical Association
Covariate-adaptive randomization procedures are frequently used in comparative studies to increase the covariate balance across treatment groups. However, because randomization inevitably uses the covariate information when forming balanced treatment groups, the validity of classical statistical methods after such randomization is often unclear. In this article, we derive the theoretical properties of statistical methods based on general covariate-adaptive randomization under the linear model framework. More importantly, we explicitly unveil the relationship between covariate-adaptive and inference properties by deriving the asymptotic representations of the corresponding estimators. We apply the proposed general theory to various randomization procedures such as complete randomization (CR), rerandomization (RR), pairwise sequential randomization (PSR), and Atkinson’s DA -biased coin design (DA -BCD) and compare their performance analytically. Based on the theoretical results, we then propose a new approach to obtain valid and more powerful tests. These results open a door to understand and analyze experiments based on covariate-adaptive randomization. Simulation studies provide further evidence of the advantages of the proposed framework and the theoretical results. Supplementary materials for this article are available online.
3 April 2015 in Journal of the American Statistical Association
Covariate-adaptive designs are often implemented to balance important covariates in clinical trials. However, the theoretical properties of conventional testing hypotheses are usually unknown under covariate-adaptive randomized clinical trials. In the literature, most studies are based on simulations. In this article, we provide theoretical foundation of hypothesis testing under covariate-adaptive designs based on linear models. We derive the asymptotic distributions of the test statistics of testing both treatment effects and the significance of covariates under null and alternative hypotheses. Under a large class of covariate-adaptive designs, (i) the hypothesis testing to compare treatment effects is usually conservative in terms of small Type I error; (ii) the hypothesis testing to compare treatment effects is usually more powerful than complete randomization; and (iii) the hypothesis testing for significance of covariates is still valid. The class includes most of the covariate-adaptive designs in the literature; for example, Pocock and Simon’s marginal procedure, stratified permuted block design, etc. Numerical studies are also performed to assess their corresponding finite sample properties. Supplementary material for this article is available online.
20 September 2022 in Journal of the American Statistical Association
In clinical trials and other comparative studies, covariate balance is crucial for credible and efficient assessment of treatment effects. Covariate adaptive randomization (CAR) procedures are extensively used to reduce the likelihood of covariate imbalances occurring. In the literature, most studies have focused on balancing of discrete covariates. Applications of CAR with continuous covariates remain rare, especially when the interest goes beyond balancing only the first moment. In this article, we propose a family of CAR procedures that can balance general covariate features, such as quadratic and interaction terms. Our framework not only unifies many existing methods, but also introduces a much broader class of new and useful CAR procedures. We show that the proposed procedures have superior balancing properties; in particular, the convergence rate of imbalance vectors is for any if all of the moments are finite for the covariate features, relative to under complete randomization, where n is the sample size. Both the resulting convergence rate and its proof are novel. These favorable balancing properties lead to increased precision of treatment effect estimation in the presence of nonlinear covariate effects. The framework is applied to balance covariate means and covariance matrices simultaneously. Simulation and empirical studies demonstrate the excellent and robust performance of the proposed procedures. Supplementary materials for this article are available online.
12 November 2020 in Journal of the American Statistical Association
Balancing important covariates is often critical in clinical trials and causal inference. Stratified permuted block (STR-PB) and covariate-adaptive randomization (CAR) procedures are widely used to balance observed covariates in practice. The balance properties of these procedures with respect to the observed covariates have been well studied. However, it has been questioned whether these methods will also yield a good balance for the unobserved covariates. In this article, we develop a general framework for the analysis of the unobserved covariates imbalance. These results are applicable to develop and compare the balance properties of complete randomization (CR), STR-PB, and CAR procedures with respect to the unobserved covariates. To quantify the improvement obtained by using STR-PB and CAR procedures rather than CR, we introduce the percentage reduction in variance of the unobserved covariates imbalance and compare these quantities. Our results demonstrate the benefits of using CAR or STR-PB (when the number of strata is small relative to the sample size) in terms of balancing unobserved covariates. These results also pave the way for future research into the effect of unobserved covariates in covariate-adaptive randomized experiments in clinical trials, as well as many other applications.
9 August 2021 in Pharmaceutical Statistics
21 July 2022 in Science China Mathematics