Widespread and continuing losses of tropical old-growth forests imperil global biodiversity and alter global carbon (C) cycling. Soil organic carbon (SOC) typically declines with land use change from old-growth forest, but the underlying mechanisms are poorly understood. Ecological restoration plantations offer an established means of restoring aboveground biomass, structure and diversity of forests, but their capacity to recover the soil microbial community and SOC is unknown due to limited empirical data and consensus on the mechanisms of SOC formation. Here, we examine soil microbial community response and SOC in tropical rainforest restoration plantings, comparing them with the original old-growth forest and the previous land use (pasture). Two decades post-reforestation, we found a statistically significant but small increase in SOC in the fast-turnover particulate C fraction. Although the δ13C signature of the more stable humic organic C (HOC) fraction indicated a significant compositional turnover in reforested soils, from C4 pasture-derived C to C3 forest-derived C, this did not translate to HOC gains compared with the pasture baseline. Matched old-growth rainforest soils had significantly higher concentrations of HOC than pasture and reforested soils, and soil microbial enzyme efficiency and the ratio of gram-positive to gram-negative bacteria followed the same pattern. Restoration plantings had unique soil microbial composition and function, distinct from baseline pasture but not converging on target old growth rainforest within the examined timeframe. Our results suggest that tropical reforestation efforts could benefit from management interventions beyond re-establishing tree cover to realize the ambition of early recovery of soil microbial communities and stable SOC.
Peatlands in Southeast Asia are considered biodiversity hotspots that contribute significantly to the global carbon cycle. Land-use change on these tropical peatlands alters chemical and physical properties of the peat which directly affect plant health and the composition, diversity and functioning of soil microbial communities. Soil microbial diversity in tropical peatlands is considerably less understood than in boreal peatlands. The aim of this study was to investigate published English-language literature on soil microbial communities in the peatlands of Indonesia, Malaysia and Brunei using a systematic quantitative literature review approach, focusing on their fungal, bacterial and archaeal soil or rhizosphere communities. Data extracted from the articles (published between 2001 and 2023) included the study location, peatland condition, peat depth, context of the research, soil microbial communities and microbial functions studied, and soil abiotic processes assessed. We found 75 studies that met the review criteria, of which the majority (45) were from Indonesia, 29 from Malaysia and one from Brunei. Soil bacteria were reported in 43 % compared to soil fungi in 32 % of these studies. Both bacteria and fungi were reported in 17 % of studies, while only 8 % of studies reported archaea, bacteria and fungi. Soil microbial functions were assessed in 52 % of studies, with considerable emphasis on enzyme activity, respiration and decomposition. Agriculture was the most common research focus (29 % of studies), followed by biodiversity (23 %) and forestry (8 %). Many studies integrated microbial richness and diversity metrics with putative functional attributes, which is an important step towards better understanding microbial activity in peatlands. Future challenges involve better understanding soil archaeal and fungal communities in Southeast Asian peatlands and the roles that they play in peatland ecosystem processes.
Reliable manipulation of soil organic matter (SOM) – a necessity for optimal land management – is constrained by our limited mechanistic understanding of SOM formation. Here we add to existing frameworks a novel mechanistic element that may underpin SOM dynamics, based on evolutionary-ecological rather than chemical or physical limitations to decomposition. We argue that decomposition of some substrates may be ecologically constrained in mycelial fungi, evolutionarily constrained in co-operating bacteria, and geometrically constrained in unicellular microbes. We describe and test a mathematical model based on our framework, providing a proof-of-concept that substrate can plausibly be spared decomposition and accumulate even when it is physically and chemically accessible. Our framework can explain a variety of SOM dynamics, including priming and the suppression of decomposition by nitrogen addition, as well as the typical composition of SOM. An augmented mechanistic framework for understanding SOM dynamics can help guide targeted empirical study, which in turn can contribute to more optimised land management.
Peatlands contain a disproportionate share of global carbon stocks, such that their biogeochemistry plays an outsized role in carbon balance and climate regulation. The precise mechanisms underpinning peat formation and stabilisation are not yet clear, with several hypotheses co-existing. Further opacity stems from a strong historical bias in research efforts towards boreal and temperate peatlands in the Northern Hemisphere, leaving the tropical case relatively under-studied. On the basis of the economics of oxidative decomposition and juxtaposition of chemical compositional data from tropical peatlands and northern peatlands, we make the case that a rapid, globally-consequential but as yet unidentified endergonic oxidation process must be occurring in tropical but not cold-climate peatlands. We suggest that low temperature limits this process in northern peatlands and, therefore, that a significant quantity of carbon in these systems is more vulnerable to warming than previously thought. We conclude that the existence of tropical peatlands - and their role in regulating global climate - may be partially underwritten by a mechanism largely unmapped by our current knowledge of soil carbon turnover.