Circular RNAs (circRNA) are covalently closed molecules that can play important roles in cancer development and progression. Hundreds of differentially expressed circRNAs between tumors and adjacent normal tissues have been identified in studies using RNA sequencing or microarrays, emphasizing a strong translational potential. Most previous studies have been performed using RNA from bulk tissues and lack information on the spatial expression patterns of circRNAs. Here, we showed that the majority of differentially expressed circRNAs from bulk tissue analyses of colon tumors relative to adjacent normal tissues were surprisingly not differentially expressed when comparing cancer cells directly with normal epithelial cells. Manipulating the proliferation rates of cells grown in culture revealed that these discrepancies were explained by circRNAs accumulating to high levels in quiescent muscle cells due to their high stability; on the contrary, circRNAs were diluted to low levels in the fast-proliferating cancer cells due to their slow biogenesis rates. Thus, different subcompartments of colon tumors and adjacent normal tissues exhibited striking differences in circRNA expression patterns. Likewise, the high circRNA content in muscle cells was also a strong confounding factor in bulk analyses of circRNAs in bladder and prostate cancers. Together, these findings emphasize the limitations of using bulk tissues for studying differential circRNA expression in cancer and highlight a particular need for spatial analysis in this field of research. Significance: The abundance of circRNAs varies systematically between subcompartments of solid tumors and adjacent tissues, implying that differentially expressed circRNAs discovered in bulk tissue analyses may reflect differences in cell type composition between samples.
CircRNAs expression patterns from tissue sub-compartments compared to colon cancer cell lines. Nanostring normalized counts for circAbParts, circABR, circAKAP12, circCCDC66, circRBM23, circSLC8A1, circSPECC1, circTNFRSF21, circZNF609, circCAMSAP1 and circXPO1 in each of the sub-compartments for each patient and compared to 4 different colon cancer cell lines.
Circular RNAs (circRNAs) are covalently closed molecules that can play important roles in cancer development and progression. Hundreds of differentially expressed circRNAs between tumors and adjacent normal tissues have been identified in studies using RNA-sequencing or microarrays, emphasizing a strong translational potential. Most previous studies have been performed using RNA from bulk tissues and lack information on the spatial expression patterns of circRNAs. Here, we showed that the majority of differentially expressed circRNAs from bulk tissue analyses of colon tumors relative to adjacent normal tissues were surprisingly not differentially expressed when comparing cancer cells directly with normal epithelial cells. Manipulating the proliferation rates of cells grown in culture revealed that these discrepancies were explained by circRNAs accumulating to high levels in quiescent muscle cells due to their high stability; on the contrary, circRNAs were diluted to low levels in the fast-proliferating cancer cells due to their slow biogenesis rates. Thus, different sub-compartments of colon tumors and adjacent normal tissues exhibited striking changes in circRNA expression patterns. Likewise, the high circRNA content in muscle cells was also a strong confounding factor in bulk analyses of circRNAs in bladder and prostate cancer. Together, these findings emphasize the limitations of using bulk tissues for studying differential circRNA expression in cancer and highlight a particular need for spatial analysis in this field of research.
Single molecule in situ hybridization for circITGA7 and circHIPK3 in colon adenocarcinoma and adjacent normal tissues. A, B. Brightfield and fluorescent microscopy images at 200X magnification. A strong signal from circITGA7 can be observed in muscle cells, whereas the epithelium, tumor stroma, and cancer cells were negative (A). A signal from circHIPK3 can be observed in the epithelium, tumor stroma, muscle, and cancer cells (B).
Tissue markers specificity. Normalized NanoString counts from specific tissue markers used for sub-compartment purity assessment after laser capture microdissection. KRT8, CDX2 and SATB2 are epithelial markers. VIM is an activated stromal marker and ACTA2 and DES are muscle cell markers. Parametric t-tests were performed to compute the p-values using the values from the cancer cells as reference. The box represents the interquartile range (Q1 and Q3), the median is marked with a horizontal line, and whiskers represent minimum and maximum values.
Circular RNAs (circRNA) are covalently closed molecules that can play important roles in cancer development and progression. Hundreds of differentially expressed circRNAs between tumors and adjacent normal tissues have been identified in studies using RNA sequencing or microarrays, emphasizing a strong translational potential. Most previous studies have been performed using RNA from bulk tissues and lack information on the spatial expression patterns of circRNAs. Here, we showed that the majority of differentially expressed circRNAs from bulk tissue analyses of colon tumors relative to adjacent normal tissues were surprisingly not differentially expressed when comparing cancer cells directly with normal epithelial cells. Manipulating the proliferation rates of cells grown in culture revealed that these discrepancies were explained by circRNAs accumulating to high levels in quiescent muscle cells due to their high stability; on the contrary, circRNAs were diluted to low levels in the fast-proliferating cancer cells due to their slow biogenesis rates. Thus, different subcompartments of colon tumors and adjacent normal tissues exhibited striking differences in circRNA expression patterns. Likewise, the high circRNA content in muscle cells was also a strong confounding factor in bulk analyses of circRNAs in bladder and prostate cancers. Together, these findings emphasize the limitations of using bulk tissues for studying differential circRNA expression in cancer and highlight a particular need for spatial analysis in this field of research.Significance:The abundance of circRNAs varies systematically between subcompartments of solid tumors and adjacent tissues, implying that differentially expressed circRNAs discovered in bulk tissue analyses may reflect differences in cell type composition between samples.