In this paper we examine two systematic observation methods intended to be used by pre-service and in-service teachers to help increase their awareness of children's participation in productive classroom dialogue. We identify the affordances of these methods for supporting teachers’ reflective practice, focusing in this case on students’ equitable participation in science groupwork activities. This involves the use of Teacher-SEDA (T-SEDA), a sub-scheme of SEDA (Cam-UNAM Scheme for Educational Dialogue Analysis), which was empirically trialled by a mixed group of researchers and teachers, using video-recordings from primary science classrooms in the UK and Mexico. The T-SEDA trials reported in this paper compare a ‘simulated live’ approach based on time-sampling techniques, with a ‘follow-up analysis’ approach, which uses audio-recordings and transcripts. The findings suggest that using either technique regularly can aid teachers in noticing classroom events and adjusting teaching accordingly. The ‘live’ coding approach appears to be the more practical method that teachers could use to audit the development of classroom equitable participation. However, the follow-up analysis emerged as a more informative approach, shedding light on more ambiguous cases of relative participation.
The study was conducted as part of a project to integrate reflective inquiry around dialogic teaching practices into university courses for teachers of Vocational and Professional Education and Training (VPET) in Switzerland. The initiative employed a toolkit for this purpose known as T-SEDA. The study explored the challenges, need for support, and mutual roles related to lecturers' involvement in practitioner-led inquiry. A design-based research approach was implemented in two phases linked to in-service courses: the first with five teachers of different subjects, the second with 13 teachers of General Culture. The course monitoring tools (interviews, surveys, teachers' artifacts, and the researcher's logbook) generated data on the lecturer's facilitation and the teachers' learning experiences. Support needs were identified, materials were developed, and the importance of face-to-face supervision was recognized, especially for an initial dialogic activity to begin observation of practice. The findings highlighted a shift from the traditional lecturer role of trainer to a facilitator role, an increase in perceived agency on the part of VPET teachers, and the overall feasibility of integrating the T-SEDA approach into university-based courses for VPET teachers. The research resulted in the design of new courses, allowing for individualized and self-directed teacher professional development in the context of highly standardized VPET requirement frameworks. It has implications for the enhancement of a reflective approach in the professional development of VPET teachers, showing possible strategies and tools for balancing external guidance – mainly for the design of dialogic activities – and teacher autonomy when defining the focus of inquiry and interpreting collected data.