Esta investigación constituye un estudio descriptivo de corte cualitativo que analiza los testimonios de 12 terapeutas especialistas en medicinas o terapias complementarias de Ciudad de México y el Estado de México con el fin de valorar si sus prácticas responden a las recomendaciones de la Estrategia de la OMS sobre medicina tradicional 2014-2023 de la Organización Mundial de la Salud. Esta organización promueve la medicina tradicional y complementaria por razones socio-económicas y culturales en países como México por su contribución al bienestar y a una atención a la salud centrada en las personas.
This study analyses the discourses of Education and Journalism students in order to understand their perception of complementary and alternative therapies. Likewise, to know if educational background or friends or acquaintances opinion has a more considerable influence on their knowledge and use of these socially controversial techniques than the media. This study uses qualitative research methods based upon 12 discussion groups with 102 participants. Once transcriptions were completed, discourse analysis was conducted using linguistic corpus software (T-LAB. 9.1.). In the design of the research, these students were selected for their social involvement in their future careers, such as when they are going to address or analyse scientific controversies, both in classrooms and media, or evidence-based medicine. Also, to complement the results of the qualitative study, and thus obtain more robust conclusions, this work compares the data collected in discussion groups, with results of a survey (quantitative research) administered to 718 students of Education, Journalism, Medicine and Nursing. One hand, the focus groups revealed that the information channels through which students learned about these therapies were by word of mouth and through networks of family members, friends and acquaintances and their digital equivalents, social networks and blogs. In all the discussion groups, a lack of scientific knowledge was detected. Second hand, survey results showed that the Education and Nursing students presented a higher level of acceptance of alternative therapies compared with the Medicine and Journalism students, who were the most unaccepting
This study analyses the discourses of Education and Journalism students in order to understand their perception of complementary and alternative therapies. Likewise, to know if educational background or friends or acquaintances opinion has a more considerable influence on their knowledge and use of these socially controversial techniques than the media. This study uses qualitative research methods based upon 12 discussion groups with 102 participants. Once transcriptions were completed, discourse analysis was conducted using linguistic corpus software (T-LAB. 9.1.). In the design of the research, these students were selected for their social involvement in their future careers, such as when they are going to address or analyse scientific controversies, both in classrooms and media, or evidence-based medicine. Also, to complement the results of the qualitative study, and thus obtain more robust conclusions, this work compares the data collected in discussion groups, with results of a survey (quantitative research) administered to 718 students of Education, Journalism, Medicine and Nursing. One hand, the focus groups revealed that the information channels through which students learned about these therapies were by word of mouth and through networks of family members, friends and acquaintances and their digital equivalents, social networks and blogs. In all the discussion groups, a lack of scientific knowledge was detected. Second hand, survey results showed that the Education and Nursing students presented a higher level of acceptance of alternative therapies compared with the Medicine and Journalism students, who were the most unaccepting
11 March 2023 in Llull, Revista de la Sociedad Española de Historia de las Ciencias y de las Técnicas
The Dictionary of Pedagogy edited in 1936 by the publishing house Labor constitutes a little-explored work despite its dimensions and scope. In the same year of its publication, the pedagogue Lorenzo Luzuriaga stated that it was a translation of Josef Spieler’s Lexikon der Pädagogik der Gegenwart (1930-1932), published by the Catholic publishing house Herder, and that Labor’s work was therefore of a confessional character. In 1960, Luzuriaga took up the subject again, this time stating that the translation was from another of Herder’s works, that of E. M. Roloff ’s Lexikon der Pädagogik. In order to assess the international influences on the content relating to science teaching in the Dictionary of Pedagogy, we set ourselves two objectives. In the first instance, to determine whether its eight entries on the teaching of scientific subjects are taken from the German dictionaries of Spieler and Roloff, as indicated by Luzuriaga. In relation to the possible German origin of that content, we evaluate its confessional nature based on the study of sex education and the contributions on this issue of the teacher trainer Margarita Comas Camps (Alaior, 1892- Exeter, 1972), one of the collaborators of the Dictionary… Secondly, we analyze the nature of the bibliographic recommendations offered by the entries in the Dictionary…. We conclude that the contents on the teaching of science subjects in the Dictionary of Pedagogy were adapted in large measure from a translation of Spieler’s Lexikon…, a detail that Labor withheld from its readers. In the field of science education, the Dictionary… exemplifies a process of appropriation of knowledge through an adapted translation that could today be interpreted as plagiarism. Nevertheless, the work facilitated the dissemination in Spain of the methodologies and resources proposed by authors close to the German New School for learning science through contact with nature, which Spanish readers would otherwise have had difficulty accessing. Our study of the bibliography of the entries also reveals the effort that Labor undertook to assemble international references from other European countries, as well as from Latin America and the USA.
8 June 2023 in CIAN-Revista de Historia de las Universidades
El Institut-Escola de la Generalitat (1931-1939) formó parte durante la Segunda República española (1931-1939) del proyecto de renovación de la enseñanza en Catalunya. En este contexto, fue concebido como un experimento pedagógico, junto a la Escola Normal de Generalitat (1931-1939), para introducir en las aulas las nuevas pedagogías, la coeducación, y el catalán, además del castellano. Este proyecto finalizó con la victoria del fascismo en España tras una Guerra Civil (1936-1939). En este artículo abordamos las relaciones del Institut-Escola, dirigido por Josep Estalella, y el Seminari de Pedagogía de la Universitat de Barcelona, por Joaquim Xirau. La coordinación entre ambos centros propició la formación del futuro profesorado de educación secundaria en las nuevas corrientes pedagógicas impulsadas por la Institución Libre de Enseñanza y su Instituto-Escuela de Madrid. En este trabajo exponemos diversos aspectos relacionados con el Seminari y la Universitat de Barcelona, así como los cursos que impartían. Nos centramos en dos formaciones relacionadas con las ciencias naturales: el curso sobre enseñanza de las ciencias físico-químicas de Estallella, y el de botánica de Pius Font i Quer, profesor de la Facultad de Farmacia. En esta última participaron tres docentes del Institut-Escola, entre ellos la profesora Àngels Ferrer i Sensat. Concluimos que la formación del profesorado de secundaria fue en dos direcciones, desde el Institut-Escola, como laboratorio práctico de experiencias pedagógicas, y desde la Universitat, como centro académico de los saberes pedagógicos.
We present the study of one of the great projects of the Barcelona publisher Editorial Labor, namely the Diccionario de Pedagogía (1936), from a new perspective: the analysis of entries on the teaching of scientific subjects. The axis of the methodologies proposed by the work is the study of living things in their natural environment from an ecological perspective, both outside the classroom via excursions and inside through aquaria, terraria, herbaria and school kitchen gardens. These methodologies can be seen to have been be influenced by New Education principles, the English Nature Study movement and the Spanish Institución Libre de Enseñanza. Coordinated by Luis Sánchez Sarto, the Diccionario de Pedagogía recorded the state of pedagogy and education worldwide, counting on a hundred or so anonymous authors most of whom were German, Austrian, American or Spanish. John Dewey, Vilhelm Rasmussen and Georg Kerschensteiner are the dictionary’s pedagogical references in science teaching. In our article, we present arguments suggesting that Margarita Comas Camps and Rafael Candel Vila were the authors of the dictionary’s two entries on teaching methodology.