Earth observation technologies have revolutionized our ability to monitor and assess environmental changes, offering unprecedented insights into the dynamics of ecosystems, land use, and climate patterns. As these technologies evolve, newer satellites like Landsat-9 (L9) offer refined capabilities that demand careful assessment of data quality and reliability improvements. With L9's enhanced radiometric resolution over Landsat-8 (L8), evaluating the impact on data accuracy and temporal resolution is crucial for ensuring consistency in long-term Earth observation and environmental monitoring. This study presents a unique way of evaluating the data consistency between two satellites by examining vegetation indices' seasonal performance and consistency from L8 and L9, focusing on NDVI, NDWI, EVI, and SAVI. Different evaluation metrics, as well as performance over different land use categories, are evaluated. This study shows that L8 generally overestimates vegetation index values compared to L9, except for SAVI, where both satellites perform similarly. L9 exhibits greater sensitivity to vegetation and water features, especially during transitional seasons such as spring and fall. The correlation between indices from both satellites remains robust, with R² values consistently exceeding 0.8, peaking at 0.92 in the fall. In the summer, L9's finer temporal resolution better captures rapid phenological changes, leading to increased variability compared to other seasons. Quantitative metrics indicate that L8 overestimates vegetation indices, with higher average RMSE (~0.05), MAE (~0.04), and a percentage bias of 4% compared to L9. This overestimation persists across most land use classes and seasons, with a notable ~15% negative bias in grassland and shrubland during the summer. L9's enhanced capabilities make it a more reliable tool for monitoring vegetation, particularly water features, in rapidly changing environments. Future research should explore a range of geographical and climatic contexts and incorporate additional indicators and high-resolution data, such as multi-spectral drone imagery, to strengthen validation efforts.