Dakota Murray

Dakota Murray

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Dakota Murray

School of Informatics, Computing, and Engineering, Indiana University

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

10Years (2017-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
5 October 2017 in Nature
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
CSCassidy R. Sugimoto
Cassidy R. Sugimoto
NRNicolás Robinson-García
Nicolás Robinson-García
DMDakota S. Murray
Dakota S. Murray
AYAlfredo Yegros-Yegros
Alfredo Yegros-Yegros
RCRodrigo Costas
Rodrigo Costas
VLVincent Larivière
Vincent Larivière

29 August 2018 in bioRxiv
Verified
Preprint
Open access
PDF file
DMDakota Murray
Dakota Murray
KSKyle Siler
Kyle Siler
VLVincent Larivière
Vincent Larivière
WCWei Mun Chan
Wei Mun Chan
ACAndrew M. Collings
Andrew M. Collings
CSCassidy R. Sugimoto
Cassidy R. Sugimoto
The fairness of scholarly peer review has been challenged by evidence of disparities in publication outcomes based on author demographic characteristics. To assess this, we conducted an exploratory analysis of peer review outcomes of 23,876 initial submissions and 7,192 full submissions that were submitted to the biosciences journal eLife between 2012 and 2017. Women and authors from nations outside of North America and Europe were underrepresented both as gatekeepers (editors and peer reviewers) and authors. We found evidence of a homophilic relationship between the demographics of the gatekeepers and authors and the outcome of peer review; that is, there were higher rates of acceptance in the case of gender and country homophily. The acceptance rate for manuscripts with male last authors was seven percent, or 3.5 percentage points, greater than for female last authors (95% CI = [0.5, 6.4]); this gender inequity was greatest, at nine percent or about 4.8 percentage points (95% CI = [0.3, 9.1]), when the team of reviewers was all male; this difference was smaller and not significantly different for mixed-gender reviewer teams. Homogeny between countries of the gatekeeper and the corresponding author was also associated with higher acceptance rates for many countries. To test for the persistence of these effects after controlling for potentially confounding variables, we conducted a logistic regression including document and author metadata. Disparities in acceptance rates associated with gender and country of affiliation and the homophilic associations remained. We conclude with a discussion of mechanisms that could contribute to this effect, directions for future research, and policy implications. Code and anonymized data have been made available at https://github.com/murrayds/elife-analysis Author summary: Peer review, the primary method by which scientific work is evaluated, is ideally a fair and equitable process in which scientific work is judged solely on its own merit. However, the integrity of peer review has been called into question based on evidence that outcomes often differ between male and female authors, and for authors in different countries. We investigated such disparities at the biosciences journal eLife by analyzing the demographics of authors and gatekeepers (editors and peer reviewers), and peer review outcomes of all submissions between 2012 and 2017. Outcomes were more favorable for male authors and those affiliated with institutions in North America and Europe; these groups were also over-represented among gatekeepers. There was evidence that peer review outcomes were influenced by homophily —a preference of gatekeepers for manuscripts from authors with shared characteristics. We discuss mechanisms that could contribute to this effect, directions for future research, and policy implications.

24 October 2017 in Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
Yi BuYi Bu
Yi Bu
YDYing Ding
Ying Ding
XLXingkun Liang
Xingkun Liang
DMDakota S. Murray
Dakota S. Murray

3 June 2020 in PLOS ONE
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
DMDakota Murray
Dakota Murray
CBClara Boothby
Clara Boothby
HZHuimeng Zhao
Huimeng Zhao
VMVanessa Minik
Vanessa Minik
NBNicolas Bérubé
Nicolas Bérubé
CSCassidy R. Sugimoto
Cassidy R. Sugimoto
Tenure-track faculty members in the United States are evaluated on their performance in both research and teaching. In spite of accusations of bias and invalidity, student evaluations of teaching have dominated teaching evaluation at U.S. universities. However, studies on the topic have tended to be limited to particular institutional and disciplinary contexts. Moreover, in spite of the idealistic assumption that research and teaching are mutually beneficial, few studies have examined the link between research performance and student evaluations of teaching. In this study, we conduct a large scale exploratory analysis of the factors associated with student evaluations of teachers, controlling for heterogeneous institutional and disciplinary contexts. We source public student evaluations of teaching from RateMyProfessor.com and information regarding career and contemporary research performance indicators from the company Academic Analytics. The factors most associated with higher student ratings were the attractiveness of the faculty and the student’s interest in the class; the factors most associated with lower student ratings were course difficulty and whether student comments mentioned an accent or a teaching assistant. Moreover, faculty tended to be rated more highly when they were young, male, White, in the Humanities, and held a rank of full professor. We observed little to no evidence of any relationship, positive or negative, between student evaluations of teaching and research performance. These results shed light on what factors relate to student evaluations of teaching across diverse contexts and contribute to the continuing discussion teaching evaluation and faculty assessment.

24 December 2021 in eLife
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
WLWout S Lamers
Wout S Lamers
KBKevin Boyack
Kevin Boyack
VLVincent Larivière
Vincent Larivière
CSCassidy R Sugimoto
Cassidy R Sugimoto
Nees Jan van EckNees Jan van Eck
Nees Jan van Eck
DMDakota Murray
Dakota Murray
Disagreement is essential to scientific progress but the extent of disagreement in science, its evolution over time, and the fields in which it happens remain poorly understood. Here we report the development of an approach based on cue phrases that can identify instances of disagreement in scientific articles. These instances are sentences in an article that cite other articles. Applying this approach to a collection of more than four million English-language articles published between 2000 and 2015 period, we determine the level of disagreement in five broad fields within the scientific literature (biomedical and health sciences; life and earth sciences; mathematics and computer science; physical sciences and engineering; and social sciences and humanities) and 817 meso-level fields. Overall, the level of disagreement is highest in the social sciences and humanities, and lowest in mathematics and computer science. However, there is considerable heterogeneity across the meso-level fields, revealing the importance of local disciplinary cultures and the epistemic characteristics of disagreement. Analysis at the level of individual articles reveals notable episodes of disagreement in science, and illustrates how methodological artifacts can confound analyses of scientific texts.

3 July 2023 in Digital Creativity
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
JLJeongki Lim
Jeongki Lim
TLTeemu Leinonen
Teemu Leinonen
LLLasse Lip­ponen
Lasse Lip­ponen
HLHenry Lee
Henry Lee
JDJulienne DeVita
Julienne DeVita
DMDakota Murray
Dakota Murray