Introduction: Whether the reduction in brain amyloid beta (Aβ) plaque alone may substantially slow cognitive and functional decline in patients with dementia or mild cognitive impairment due to Alzheimer's disease (AD) remains debated.Methods: An instrumental variable meta‐analysis was performed to infer the effect of change in positron emission tomography (PET)–measured Aβ standardized uptake value ratio (SUVR) on cognitive and functional decline.Results: Pooling data from 16 randomized trials demonstrates that each 0.1‐unit decrease in PET Aβ SUVR is associated with a reduction (95% confidence interval) by 0.09 (0.034–0.15), 0.33 (0.12–0.55), and 0.13 (0.017–0.24) point in the average change of the Clinical Dementia Rating–Sum of Boxes, the Alzheimer's Disease Assessment Scale–Cognitive Subscale, and the Mini‐Mental State Examination, respectively.Discussion: This meta‐analysis provides statistically significant evidence of a likely causal relationship between a reduction in Aβ plaque and a reduction in cognitive and functional decline in patients with AD.Highlights: A widely cited meta‐analysis article concluded amyloid beta reduction does not substantially improve cognition. We identified data inconsistencies in the initial publication and found new trial data. We repeated the meta‐analysis after correcting data inconsistencies and adding new trial data. Updated results suggested statistically significant clinical benefit of amyloid beta reduction. Amyloid beta is a viable biological target for the treatment and prevention of AD.
4 December 2015 in The International Journal of Biostatistics
Inverse probability of treatment weighting (IPW) and targeted maximum likelihood estimation (TMLE) are relatively new methods proposed for estimating marginal causal effects. TMLE is doubly robust, yielding consistent estimators even under misspecification of either the treatment or the outcome model. While IPW methods are known to be sensitive to near violations of the practical positivity assumption (e. g., in the case of data sparsity), the consequences of this violation in the TMLE framework for binary outcomes have been less widely investigated. As near practical positivity violations are particularly likely in high-dimensional covariate settings, a better understanding of the performance of TMLE is of particular interest for pharmcoepidemiological studies using large databases. Using plasmode and Monte-Carlo simulation studies, we evaluated the performance of TMLE compared to that of IPW estimators based on a point-exposure cohort study of the marginal causal effect of post-myocardial infarction statin use on the 1-year risk of all-cause mortality from the Clinical Practice Research Datalink. A variety of treatment model specifications were considered, inducing different degrees of near practical non-positivity. Our simulation study showed that the performance of the TMLE and IPW estimators were comparable when the dimension of the fitted treatment model was small to moderate; however, they differed when a large number of covariates was considered. When a rich outcome model was included in the TMLE, estimators were unbiased. In some cases, we found irregular bias and large standard errors with both methods even with a correctly specified high-dimensional treatment model. The IPW estimator showed a slightly better root MSE with high-dimensional treatment model specifications in our simulation setting. In conclusion, for estimation of the marginal expectation of the outcome under a fixed treatment, TMLE and IPW estimators employing the same treatment model specification may perform differently due to differential sensitivity to practical positivity violations; however, TMLE, being doubly robust, shows improved performance with richer specifications of the outcome model. Although TMLE is appealing for its double robustness property, such violations in a high-dimensional covariate setting are problematic for both methods.
21 September 2021 in Statistical Methods in Medical Research
The accelerated failure time model is an alternative to the Cox proportional hazards model in survival analysis. However, conclusions regarding the associations of prognostic factors with event times are valid only if the underlying modeling assumptions are met. In contrast to several flexible methods for relaxing the proportional hazards and linearity assumptions in the Cox model, formal investigation of the constant-over-time time ratio and linearity assumptions in the accelerated failure time model has been limited. Yet, in practice, prognostic factors may have time-dependent and/or nonlinear effects. Furthermore, parametric accelerated failure time models require correct specification of the baseline hazard function, which is treated as a nuisance parameter in the Cox proportional hazards model, and is rarely known in practice. To address these challenges, we propose a flexible extension of the accelerated failure time model where unpenalized regression B-splines are used to model (i) the baseline hazard function of arbitrary shape, (ii) the time-dependent covariate effects on the hazard, and (iii) nonlinear effects for continuous covariates. Simulations evaluate the accuracy of the time-dependent and/or nonlinear estimates, and of the resulting survival functions, in multivariable settings. The proposed flexible extension of the accelerated failure time model is applied to re-assess the effects of prognostic factors on mortality after septic shock.