Shane A. Richards

Shane A. Richards

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Shane A. Richards

School of Natural Sciences, University of Tasmania, Australia

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

31Years (1996-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
18 October 2007 in Journal of Applied Ecology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SRShane A. Richards
Shane A. Richards
Summary: The ability to identify key ecological processes is important when solving applied problems. Increasingly, ecologists are adopting Akaike's information criterion (AIC) as a metric to help them assess and select among multiple process‐based ecological models. Surprisingly, however, it is still unclear how best to incorporate AIC into the selection process in order to address the trade‐off between maximizing the probability of retaining the most parsimonious model while minimizing the number of models retained. Ecological count data are often observed to be overdispersed with respect to best‐fitting models. Overdispersion is problematic when performing an AIC analysis, as it can result in selection of overly complex models which can lead to poor ecological inference. This paper describes and illustrates two approaches that deal effectively with overdispersion. The first approach involves modelling the causes of overdispersion implicitly using compound probability distributions. The second approach ignores the causes of overdispersion and uses quasi‐AIC (QAIC) as a metric for model parsimony. Simulations and a novel method that identifies the most parsimonious model are used to demonstrate the utility of the two overdispersion approaches within the context of two ecological examples. The first example addresses binomial data obtained from a study of fish survival (as related to habitat structure) and the second example addresses Poisson data obtained from a study of flower visitation by nectarivores. Applying either overdispersion approach reduces the chance of selecting overly complex models, and both approaches result in very similar ecological inference. In addition, inference can be made more reliable by incorporating model nesting into the selection process (i.e. identifying which models are special cases of others), as it reduces the number of models selected without significantly reducing the probability of retaining the most parsimonious models. Synthesis and applications. When data are overdispersed, inference can be improved by either modelling the causes of overdispersion or applying QAIC as a metric for model parsimony. Inference can also be improved by adopting a model filtering procedure based on how models are nested. The general simulation approach presented in this paper for identifying the most parsimonious model, as defined by information theory, should help to improve our understanding of the reliability of model selection when using AIC, and help the development of better selection rules.

10 March 2002 in Ecology Letters
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JCJonathan M. Chase
Jonathan M. Chase
PAPeter A. Abrams
Peter A. Abrams
JGJames P. Grover
James P. Grover
SDSebastian Diehl
Sebastian Diehl
PCPeter Chesson
Peter Chesson
TCTed J. Case
Ted J. Case
This review discusses the interface between two of the most important types of interactions between species, interspecific competition and predation. Predation has been claimed to increase, decrease, or have little effect on, the strength, impact or importance of interspecific competition. There is confusion about both the meaning of these terms and the likelihood of, and conditions required for, each of these outcomes. In this article we distinguish among three measures of the influence of predation on competitive outcomes: short‐term per capita consumption or growth rates, long‐term changes in density, and the probability of competitive coexistence. We then outline various theoretical mechanisms that can lead to qualitatively distinct effects of predators. The qualitative effect of predators can depend both on the mechanism of competition and on the definition of competitive strength/impact. In assessing the empirical literature, we ask: (1) What definitions of competitive strength/impact have been assumed? (2) Does strong evidence exist to support one or more of the possible mechanisms that can produce a given outcome? (3) Do biases in the choice of organism or manipulation exist, and are they likely to have influenced the conclusions reached? We conclude by discussing several unanswered questions, and espouse a stronger interchange between empirical and theoretical approaches to this important question.


3 January 2023 in Ecological Monographs
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
LYLuke A. Yates
Luke A. Yates
ZAZach Aandahl
Zach Aandahl
SRShane A. Richards
Shane A. Richards
BBBarry Brook
Barry Brook
Specifying, assessing, and selecting among candidate statistical models is fundamental to ecological research. Commonly used approaches to model selection are based on predictive scores and include information criteria such as Akaike's information criterion, and cross validation. Based on data splitting, cross validation is particularly versatile because it can be used even when it is not possible to derive a likelihood (e.g., many forms of machine learning) or count parameters precisely (e.g., mixed‐effects models). However, much of the literature on cross validation is technical and spread across statistical journals, making it difficult for ecological analysts to assess and choose among the wide range of options. Here we provide a comprehensive, accessible review that explains important—but often overlooked—technical aspects of cross validation for model selection, such as: bias correction, estimation uncertainty, choice of scores, and selection rules to mitigate overfitting. We synthesize the relevant statistical advances to make recommendations for the choice of cross‐validation technique and we present two ecological case studies to illustrate their application. In most instances, we recommend using exact or approximate leave‐one‐out cross validation to minimize bias, or otherwise k‐fold with bias correction if k < 10. To mitigate overfitting when using cross validation, we recommend calibrated selection via our recently introduced modified one‐standard‐error rule. We advocate for the use of predictive scores in model selection across a range of typical modeling goals, such as exploration, hypothesis testing, and prediction, provided that models are specified in accordance with the stated goal. We also emphasize, as others have done, that inference on parameter estimates is biased if preceded by model selection and instead requires a carefully specified single model or further technical adjustments.

19 August 2010 in Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
SRShane A. Richards
Shane A. Richards
MWMark J. Whittingham
Mark J. Whittingham
PSPhilip Stephens
Philip Stephens

6 April 2020 in Nature Ecology & Evolution
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
AAAsta Audzijonyte
Asta Audzijonyte
SRShane A. Richards
Shane A. Richards
RSRick D. Stuart-Smith
Rick D. Stuart-Smith
GPGretta Pecl
Gretta Pecl
GEGraham J. Edgar
Graham J. Edgar
JBJulia L. Blanchard
Julia L. Blanchard