What happens when the findings of a prominent medical study are overturned? Using a medical trial on breech births, we estimate the effect of the reversal of such a medical study on physician choices and infant health outcomes. Using the United States Birth Certificate Records from 1995-2010, we employ a difference-in-differences estimator for C-sections, low Apgar, and low birth weight measures. We find that the reversal of a multi-site, high profile, randomized control trial on the appropriate delivery of term breech births, the Term Breech Trial (TBT), led to a 15-23 percent decline in C-sections for such births at a time when the overall trend in C-sections was rising. We find our largest estimated effects amongst traditionally disadvantaged groups. However, we do not find that such a change in practice had significant impacts on infant health. Contrary to prior studies, we find that physicians updated their beliefs quickly, and do indeed adjust to new medical research, particularly young physicians, prior to mandatory policy or professional guidelines.
13 September 2025 in Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization
We examine the effects of prenatal exposure to fine particulate matter (PM2.5) on birth outcomes in a low-pollution setting. We combine administrative birth records in Quebec between 2008 and 2015 with air quality monitoring data and linked tax records in h neighborhood-by-quarter fixed effects models. While we find little evidence that prenatal PM2.5 exposure substantially affects birth outcomes on average at the population level, we unmask important heterogeneity. Constructing a cumulative socioeconomic vulnerability index, we find that in most vulnerable families a 1μg/m3 increase in average PM2.5 exposure is associated with a reduction of approximately 6.6 grams in birth weight. Focusing on a sample of births admitted to one of the province's neonatal care unit, we also find important effects of in utero PM2.5 exposure on biologically vulnerable newborns, both in terms of prematurity and of birth weight. We also find that days exceeding the Canadian 24-hour PM2.5 standard have disproportionately large effects among vulnerable families, such that peaks in exposure matter beyond average exposure itself.