This study investigates gender differences in the entrepreneurial mindset (EM) amongsports management Master’s students with prior entrepreneurial exposure. A total of 350 students participated by completing an adapted version of the Scale to Assess Social Entrepreneurship Competency. The instrument was validated through exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses, supporting a six-factor structure—Creativity and Innovation, Risk-taking, Strategic Leadership, Goal Orientation, Action-based Learning, and Ethical Responsibility—which explained 64.3% of the total variance (CFI = 0.93, TLI = 0.91, RMSEA = 0.048). Multivariate analysis of variance revealed significant gender differences (Wilks’ Λ = 0.84, F(6, 340) = 10.21, η² = 0.15). Male students reported higher levels of Risk-taking, Strategic Leadership, and Goal Orientation, whereas no significant differences were found in Creativity and Innovation, Action-based Learning, or Ethical Responsibility. Regression analyses indicated that entrepreneurial background positively predicted Risk-taking and Strategic Leadership, while sports experience showed a marginal association with Goal Orientation. Gender emerged as the most consistent predictor across models. These findings underline persistent gender disparities in EM and emphasize the importance of gender-responsive educational strategies, including mentorship and experiential learning, to foster inclusive entrepreneurial development in higher education contexts.