Background: Designing climate-resilient, low-input irrigated wheat-based cover-cropping systems in semi-arid environments requires soil-rehabilitation strategies that bypass traditional, resource-intensive summer fallows.,Methods: A four-year fixed-plot field experiment (2017/18–2020/21) was conducted at the Grassland Research Farm of the Seed and Plant Improvement Institute, Karaj, Alborz Province, Iran, to evaluate the cumulative system-level effects of sixteen summer green manure cover crop (SGMCC) monocultures — cereals, legumes and a brassica — plus a bare/weedy summer-fallow check, under a conservation-oriented double minimum tillage (DMT) framework. Wheat (cv. Baharan) grain yield and yield components, physiological indices, bread-making quality, soil organic carbon (SOC), and system-level economics were monitored across four consecutive wheat cycles in a randomized complete block design with three replications.,Results: In each individual cropping season, differences among cover-crop treatments in wheat grain yield were not statistically significant. However, combined multi-year analysis revealed a highly significant effect of cropping year (P < 0.01) and cumulative legacy effects of cover cropping. Over the four-year period, mean wheat grain yield rose steadily from 6,760 kg ha⁻¹ (baseline) to 8,380 kg ha⁻¹ (Year 4), a 24% increase, with a fitted linear trend explaining 87% of the yield variation (R² = 0.87). This increase paralleled a rise in soil organic carbon from 0.45% (baseline) to 1.40% (Year 4) — an approximately three-fold increase — together with improved soil structure, a more balanced bacterial:fungal microbial community, and higher 1000-kernel weight (48.1 g in Year 1 to 50.9 g in Year 4).,Key findings: Although the bare/weedy summer-fallow check produced a transient yield peak in Year 4 (10,171 kg ha⁻¹, driven by unimpeded mineralization of native soil organic matter), it did not sequester carbon and is agronomically unsustainable. Among the cover crops, forage millet (Pennisetum glaucum, cv. Bastan) and crimson clover (Trifolium incarnatum) were consistently the top performers: forage millet achieved the highest single-year cover-crop yield (9,518 kg ha⁻¹ in Year 4) and the best economic return (net present value 124.1 million Iranian Rials ha⁻¹, ≈ 540 USD ha⁻¹; return on investment 73.1%), while crimson clover produced the highest four-year cumulative economic value (953 million Rials ha⁻¹). AMMI and multivariate stability analyses converged on forage millet, crimson clover, canola and grain sorghum as the most productive and stable species, with benefits plateauing after approximately three consecutive years of implementation,Conclusions: Replacing long, bare summer fallows with two- to three-week mid-summer green manure cover cropping under double minimum tillage is a technically viable, economically profitable and ecologically sustainable management package for irrigated smallholder wheat systems in semi-arid, temperate-cold regions, provided it is maintained for at least three consecutive years to allow cumulative soil legacy effects to be expressed.