Charles Plante

Charles Plante

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Charles Plante

Research Department, Saskatchewan Health Authority

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

14Years (2013-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
19 April 2024 in medRxiv
Verified
Preprint
Open access
PDF file
CPCharles Plante
Charles Plante
SMSharalynn Missiuna
Sharalynn Missiuna
CNCordell Neudorf
Cordell Neudorf
Self-rated health is a widely used indicator of overall health status. It is most often reported on a Likert scale of three to five values in surveys. To facilitate presentation and interpretation, it is common practice to simplify the variable by dichotomizing it; however, there has been little documented reflection on how this should be done. This paper explores all four possible dichotomizations of self-reported health, taken from three years of the Canadian Community Health Survey and reported by a Likert scale. We evaluated each dichotomization stratified by sociodemographic variables. We use regression analysis to explore the validity and reliability of all four possible dichotomizations by mapping them to the Health Utility Index. We found that lower cutpoints of dichotomization capture more pronounced differences in health status and are more consistent across sociodemographic variables. However, higher cutpoints of dichotomization should be considered for small data sets. About the Research Department The Saskatchewan Health Authority Research Department leads collaborative research to enhance Saskatchewan’s health and healthcare. We provide diverse research services to SHA staff, clinicians, and team members, including surveys, study design, database development, statistical analysis, and assistance with research funding. We also spearhead our own research programs to strengthen research and analytic capability and learning within Saskatchewan’s health system. About the UPHN The Urban Public Health Network (UPHN) is a national organization established in 2004 which today includes the Medical Officers of Health in 24 of Canada’s large urban centres. Working collaboratively and with a collective voice, the network addresses public health issues that are common to urban populations. Research operations of the UPHN are conducted in partnership with the University of Saskatchewan. Disclaimer This working paper is for discussion and comment purposes. It has not been peer-reviewed nor been subject to review by Research Department staff or executives. Any opinions expressed in this paper are those of the author(s) and not those of the Saskatchewan Health Authority. Suggested Citation Charles Plante, Sharalynn Missiuna, and Cordell Neudorf. 2024. “The Validity and Reliability of Dichotomized Self-rated Health Under Different Cutpoints.” medRxiv. Introduction Self-rated health is a widely used indicator of overall health status. It is most often reported on a Likert scale of three to five values in surveys. To facilitate presentation and interpretation, it is common practice to simplify the variable by dichotomizing it; however, little documented reflection has been done on how this should be done. Methods We use regression analysis to explore the validity and reliability of all four possible dichotomizations of self-reported health in the Canadian Community Health Survey in 2013-2015 by mapping them to a validated health measure: the Health Utility Index Mark 3 (HUI). We posit that more valid cutpoints in self-rated health are associated with larger changes in HUI. We posit further that more reliable cutpoints are associated with similar changes across sociodemographic variables, including age, sex, education, marital status, geography and income. We also provide descriptive statistics to contextualize our analysis. Results The greatest proportion of respondents reported having “very good” health, although the proportion of the population reporting “excellent” or “very good” health decreased with age. Similarly, Canadians tend to score highly in HUI. Our regression results suggest that HUI tends to be higher for younger, richer, married, educated and urban populations. However, these associations are muted as the cutpoint used to dichotomize self-reported health is raised. The model with the lowest cutpoint, distinguishing between poor health and all other health statuses, was associated with the greatest and most consistent negative changes in HUI among different sociodemographic groups. Conclusions Dichotomizing self-rated health using lower cutpoints captures more pronounced differences in health status measured by HUI and tends to capture more consistent differences across sociodemographic variables. That is, lower cutpoints produce more valid and reliable results. However, lower cutpoints isolate less commonly reported health levels and may lead to less accurate results in smaller populations. Key Points This article addresses the knowledge gap concerning the most accurate way to dichotomize self-rated health data reported using a Likert scale. This paper explores the validity and reliability of all four possible dichotomizations of self-reported health reported by a Likert scale. Lower cutpoints of dichotomization capture more pronounced differences in health status and are more consistent across sociodemographic variables. Higher cutpoints of dichotomization should be considered for small data sets.

14 December 2018 in Journal of International and Comparative Social Policy
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
CPCharles Plante
Charles Plante
Poverty reduction strategies (PRS) have become a popular instrument for addressing poverty globally. According to their proponents, PRS focus and coordinate poverty reduction efforts in order to overcome traditional economic and socio-demographic obstacles and reduce poverty unconditionally. According to their detractors, however, governments use PRS as ‘window dressing’ to gloss over unsuccessful and/or partial poverty reduction efforts. In Canada, all ten provinces have committed to adopting PRS. In this study, I identify the timing of the introduction of PRS action plans and explore whether they have tended to coincide with changes in provincial poverty levels. I find that more often than not levels have actually dropped before rather than after the introduction of PRS. This suggests that governments may have indeed used PRS as window dressing – but to showcase and claim credit for poverty reduction successes.

20 April 2021 in Canadian Journal of Public Health
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
SMSharalynn Missiuna
Sharalynn Missiuna
CPCharles Plante
Charles Plante
PPPunam Pahwa
Punam Pahwa
NMNazeem Muhajarine
Nazeem Muhajarine
CNCordell Neudorf
Cordell Neudorf

12 June 2013 in Sociologie Et Societes
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
HRHicham Raïq
Hicham Raïq
CPCharles Plante
Charles Plante
Le Québec a réalisé des progrès remarquables sur le plan de la lutte à la pauvreté chez les familles et particulièrement les monoparentales. Sur la dernière décennie, ses taux de pauvreté étaient souvent plus faibles que le reste du Canada. Le but de cet article est d’explorer une nouvelle approche longitudinale de la pauvreté pour voir si le Québec conserve toujours sa position de leader. Cette approche cherche à comprendre comment les familles québécoises peuvent être confrontées à la pauvreté dans leur parcours de vie. Nos résultats montrent que les familles monoparentales dans les autres principales provinces canadiennes ont été plus souvent touchées par des périodes de pauvreté entre 2002 et 2007 comparativement au Québec. Par contre, lorsque la pauvreté frappe ces ménages, le temps nécessaire pour remonter la pente est presque le même quelle que soit la province de résidence.

21 March 2024 in Discover Social Science and Health
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
AMAnousheh Marouzi
Anousheh Marouzi
CPCharles Plante
Charles Plante
CNCordell Neudorf
Cordell Neudorf
Introduction: Avoidable mortality is widely used by public health researchers to measure population health, and many related methodologies have been proposed for doing so. This scoping review presents a comprehensive view of global peer-reviewed and grey literature exploring the association between socioeconomic status (SES) and avoidable mortality. Methods: We searched Ovid Medline, Scopus, and Web of Science to find articles that investigated SES inequalities in avoidable mortality. We limited our review to articles in English published between 2000 and 2020. For grey literature, we searched leading global and Canadian health information websites. We extracted data on different study characteristics, avoidable mortality definition, SES indicator, method of analysis of the association between avoidable mortality and SES, and main findings of the studies. Results: We identified 34 articles to review, including 29 scientific papers and 5 grey literature documents. The findings of the selected articles consistently indicate a negative association between SES and avoidable mortality rates. Studies have not all used the same definitions of avoidable mortality or SES nor operationalized them in the same way. Conclusion: Our review highlights the absence of a globally standard definition in avoidable mortality health equity research. Additional work to establish a standardized definition is crucial for supporting global comparability.

2 December 2022 in Canadian Journal of Public Health
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
CPCharles Plante
Charles Plante
NSNavdeep Sandhu
Navdeep Sandhu
TBThilina Bandara
Thilina Bandara
DFDaniel Fuller
Daniel Fuller
CNCordell Neudorf
Cordell Neudorf