Bivalves play a key role in coastal ecosystems and provide society with many ecosystem services. Anthropogenic activities produce a multitude of interacting stressors which can cause unexpected responses in the physiology, behaviour, condition, development, reproduction and survival of bivalves. Responses can be (1) additive: the response is the sum of the effect of individual stressors, (2) synergistic: the combined effect is greater than the sum of individual stressors or, (3) antagonistic: the combined effect is smaller than the sum of individual stressors. There has been a proliferation of research on the effects of multiple stressors on marine bivalves but an evaluation of the literature in the context of management and restoration has not been undertaken. This review and meta-analysis aimed to determine bivalves’ responses to stressor interactions and identify research trends and gaps. The meta-analysis highlights a prevalence of antagonistic and additive responses to stressors and an overall antagonistic effect. The observed antagonistic responses may be associated with how multiple stressor studies are being conducted. The literature demonstrates a bias towards individual-level laboratory experiments that focus on responses of adult bivalves to climate-change related ‘global’ stressors. Suggestions for future research include an emphasis on (1) ‘local’ stressors, (2) earlier life stages, and (3) field-based studies incorporating stressor gradients and spatiotemporal variability. These investigations will complement the existing knowledge base and ultimately provide a more complete picture of the impacts of multiple stressors on bivalves– information that is vital for management decision-making and restoration of bivalve populations.
In northern New Zealand, there is speculation that predation by a recovering shorebird, the South Island Pied Oystercatcher (Haematopus finschi), has caused the continuing decline of an endemic surf clam, the toheroa (Paphies ventricosa). Consequently, there have been requests by the public for these protected birds to be culled to protect and restore the toheroa. To better inform management and decision-making for these species we set out to understand the impact of oystercatcher predation on toheroa at Ripiro Beach in New Zealand. A study was conducted to establish the spatio-temporal overlap of toheroa and oystercatcher distributions, determine oystercatcher prey selection, and assess the impacts of oystercatcher predation on toheroa population size structure. Monthly surveys over a 12-month period indicated limited spatial overlap between the two species, and that most toheroa beds on Ripiro Beach are not subjected to oystercatcher predation. In areas where oystercatchers and toheroa co-occurred, oystercatchers consumed a variety of prey including polychaetes, small and medium-sized toheroa and a non-threatened surf clam (P. subtriangulata). While oystercatchers do feed on toheroa (and may be capable of locally reducing abundance of small toheroa in a population), feeding on larger individuals (>50 mm in length) was not observed. These results suggest that culling of oystercatchers would be of no benefit for the recovery of toheroa populations. It is likely that less obvious factors are impeding the recovery of toheroa in New Zealand. This study highlights the importance of understanding predator-prey interactions before implementing management actions such as lethal control.
Estuarine ecosystems are experiencing increasing land‐derived stress, bringing sediments, excess nutrients and contaminants. Once degraded, disturbed soft sediment ecosystems can take years to recover because long‐lived, functionally important species that aid recovery are lost. We undertook an experiment in the Tauranga Harbour, transplanting adult Austrovenus stutchburyi (>18 mm at 800 ind. m −2 ) to nine sites across a stressor gradient of increasing sedimentation, nutrient and heavy metal loading. The goal of this study was to test levels of retention across this gradient and whether transplanting suspension‐feeding clams will improve ecosystem functioning. Measures of ecosystem function (benthic metabolism, organic matter degradation) and sediment characteristics were compared with ambient (non‐addition) plots after 3 months. Transplanted A. stutchburyi retention (28%–75%) varied across sites and was not correlated with the overall stress gradient. The sediment heavy metal load, particularly zinc levels, reduced translocated clam retention despite being well below contamination guideline levels. Ecosystem functions did not differ between treatment and ambient plots; however, when normalised against each site's ambient mean values, organic matter degradation scaled with retention, isolating the effect of the added clams on carbon turnover. This study illustrates that restoration of some functions in degraded soft sediments by A. stutchburyi transplantation is possible, but its success will depend on whether heavy metals have been reduced and the identification of other, less expected, stressors that may reduce clam retention.