Purpose: Previous research on perceived underqualification has primarily focused on the fit perspective or social comparison perspective, with limited attention given to the identity-related perspective. Drawing upon the self-affirmation theory, this study investigates how young employees' perceived underqualification influences their job search behavior and examines the moderating role of forgone identity dwelling. Design/methodology/approach: We conducted two empirical studies including a three-wave field survey and a scenario experiment. Findings: Our findings indicate that young employees' perceived underqualification negatively affected state self-esteem, which in turn increased job search behavior. Moreover, forgone identity dwelling weakened the negative effect of perceived underqualification on state self-esteem. Originality/value: These findings enhance our understanding of perceived underqualification from the identity-related perspective, extend self-affirmation theory by incorporating the concept of the forgone self and contribute to forgone identity dwelling research by pointing out its new mechanism.