Oceanic anoxia—including euxinic settings defined by the presence of water column hydrogen sulfide (H2S)—is minor in the ocean today. Such conditions, however, were common or even dominant in the past, particularly during the Precambrian and Phanerozoic oceanic anoxic events. The latter are associated with massive petroleum and mineral reserves and many of the major extinction events in the paleontological record. Our ability to recognize ancient oxygen deficiencies relies strongly on paleontological data viewed in combination with geochemical tracers, and geochemistry is typically our only window onto ancient marine redox during the Precambrian when diagnostic skeletal and behaviorial traces of oxygen-dependent animals are mostly missing. So far no approach has gained wider acceptance than the iron proxies, which rely generally on quantification of the extent to which reactive iron (as oxides principally) is converted to pyrite. The promise of these approaches lies in part with the relative ease of measurement, but it is this ease and the corresponding widespread use that has also led to misuses.
1 February 2019 in Earth and Planetary Science Letters
Carbonates from approximately 2.3–2.1 billion years ago show markedly positive δ 13 C values commonly reaching and sometimes exceeding +10‰. Traditional interpretation of these positive δ 13 C values favors greatly enhanced organic carbon burial on a global scale, although other researchers have invoked widespread methanogenesis within the sediments. To resolve between these competing models and, more generally, among the mechanisms behind Earth’s most dramatic carbon isotope event, we obtained coupled stable isotope data for carbonate carbon and carbonate-associated sulfate (CAS). CAS from the Lomagundi interval shows a narrow range of δ 34 S values and concentrations much like those of Phanerozoic and modern marine carbonate rocks. The δ 34 S values are a close match to those of coeval sulfate evaporites and likely reflect seawater composition. These observations are inconsistent with the idea of diagenetic carbonate formation in the methanic zone. Toward the end of the carbon isotope excursion there is an increase in the δ 34 S values of CAS. We propose that these trends in C and S isotope values track the isotopic evolution of seawater sulfate and reflect an increase in pyrite burial and a crash in the marine sulfate reservoir during ocean deoxygenation in the waning stages of the positive carbon isotope excursion.
29 October 2013 in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
Significance: Oxygen in the atmosphere and ocean rose dramatically about 600 Mya, coinciding with the first proliferation of animals. However, numerous biotic events followed when oxygen concentrations in the younger ocean dipped episodically. The Cretaceous is famous for such episodes, and the most extensive of these oceanic anoxic events occurred 93.9 Mya. Our combined carbon- and sulfur-isotope data indicate that oxygen-free and hydrogen sulfide-rich waters extended across roughly 5% of the global ocean, compared to <<1% today, but with the likelihood that much broader regions were also oxygen challenged. These conditions must have impacted nutrient availability in the ocean and ultimately the spatial and temporal distribution of marine life across a major climatic perturbation.
11 June 2018 in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
Significance: Declining oxygen contents in today’s oceans highlight the need to better understand ancient, natural marine deoxygenation and associated extinctions. In the Early Jurassic, the Toarcian Oceanic Anoxic Event (T-OAE; ∼183 Ma) is associated with significant perturbations to the Earth system, historically defined by carbon isotopes. We reconstructed global oceanic (de)oxygenation using thallium isotopes from two ocean basins that suggest a stepwise decline of oxygen that initiated before and extended well after the classically defined T-OAE interval. This initial deoxygenation occurs with the start of massive volcanism and marine extinctions, while a later shift corresponds to the traditional T-OAE. This emphasizes the need for more nuanced records of ancient environmental and biogeochemical feedbacks that lead to and maintain widespread marine anoxia.