Alcohol and other drug (AOD) use disorders are stigmatized conditions, but little is known about youth’s experience of this stigma, which may threaten their developing social identity and recovery process. This study investigates youth’s perceptions of AOD use-related stigma in the context of their social identity. This study uses data from 12 youth (ages 17–19) who were in recovery from problematic AOD use. Participants completed a Social Identity Mapping in Addiction Recovery (SIM-AR) exercise, in which they created a visual map of their social groups, and semi-structured interview, in which participants were asked about their experience creating their SIM-AR and reflections on their social network. SIM-AR data were descriptively analyzed, and interviews were thematically analyzed for instances of stigma. Using stigmatizing terminology, participants expressed some stigmatizing attitudes towards themselves and others in their network who used substances and perceived both positive and negative reactions from those who knew about their disorder. Findings suggest that youth may experience some internalized stigma and perceive stigma from others in their social networks, which may be a barrier to the development of a healthy social identity and engagement in recovery supports. These findings should be considered when seeking to engage youth in treatment and recovery programming. Despite the small sample, the findings suggest the importance of considering how stigma may influence adolescents’ treatment and recovery experience in the context of their social environment.
Background: Social recovery capital (SRC) refers to resources and supports gained through relationships and is vital to adolescent addiction recovery. Much is known about how substance use relates to social networks, but little is known about how other dimensions of social networks influence recovery (e.g., network size/exposure, degree of conflict). Methods: This mixed-methods study sampled 28 adolescents who received treatment for alcohol and other drug (AOD) use disorder (14-19 yrs.: 71% male; M = 17.32 yrs., SD = 1.33; White 82%): 20 were recovery high school (RHS) students. Adolescents completed a social identity map for addiction recovery (SIM-AR), survey, and interview. Qualitative data were content analyzed and the data from the SIM-AR were quantified. Results: On average, participants reported belonging to five distinct groups within their network (Range, 2-9; SD = 1.63; M = 27.89 people, SD = 20.09). Of their social network connections, 51% drank alcohol and 46% used other substances, on average. Larger networks involved more conflict (r = 0.57). Participants were more likely to spend more time with groups that had greater proportions of non-substance-using members. These linkages were stronger for RHS than for non-RHS students. Qualitative analyses revealed that youth reported their recovery-oriented groups as supportive, but some reported that their substance-using friends also supported their recovery. Discussion: SIM-AR was a useful measurement tool, and, through qualitative interviews, we identified unique aspects of youths' social networks important for further examination. Research with recovering youth should examine SRC-related elements within their networks including relationship quality, belonging, and conflict, alongside the substance use behaviors of network members.
11 October 2023 in Evaluation and Program Planning
We assessed the extent to which portrayals of AUD treatment effectiveness influenced multiple domains of stigma. This cross-sectional, whole-population survey experiment was conducted with 1363 adults living in eight villages of southwestern Uganda in 2021-2022. Participants were randomly assigned to receive a vignette describing a typical man (control) or one of six vignette variants describing a man with untreated AUD, treated AUD, or other variations of treated or untreated AUD with differing outcomes. personal willingness to have the man marry into their family, belief that he is receiving divine punishment, and belief that he brings shame on his family. Participants also reported their perceptions about whether most people in their villages would hold those stigmatizing attitudes (i.e., perceived norms). We fitted multivariable Poisson regression models to estimate the effect of vignette assignment on personal beliefs and perceived norms. Participants reported more stigmatizing personal beliefs across all AUD vignettes compared to control. Average marginal effects (AME) of assignment on the excess probability of stigmatizing personal beliefs ranged from 0.57 (95 % Confidence Interval CI=0.43-0.71) to 0.74 (CI=0.58-0.90) for unwillingness to have the man marry into their family, 0.66 (CI=0.53-0.80) to 0.81 (CI=0.67-0.95) for believing the man brings shame upon his family, and 0.29 (CI=0.20-0.38) to 0.36 (CI=0.27-0.46) for believing the man is receiving divine punishment. AMEs of vignette assignment on perceived norms were similar. Stigma toward men with AUD in rural Uganda was high regardless of AUD treatment effectiveness. Culturally-tailored stigma reduction interventions are needed.