8 August 2011 in Arthroscopy
1 October 2017 in Ophthalmology
1 July 2021 in Journal of Surgical Education
To test whether crowdsourced lay raters can accurately assess cataract surgical skills. Two-armed study: independent cross-sectional and longitudinal cohorts. Washington University Department of Ophthalmology. Sixteen cataract surgeons with varying experience levels submitted cataract surgery videos to be graded by 5 experts and 300+ crowdworkers masked to surgeon experience. Cross-sectional study: 50 videos from surgeons ranging from first-year resident to attending physician, pooled by years of training. Longitudinal study: 28 videos obtained at regular intervals as residents progressed through 180 cases. Surgical skill was graded using the modified Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skill (mOSATS). Main outcome measures were overall technical performance, reliability indices, and correlation between expert and crowd mean scores. Experts demonstrated high interrater reliability and accurately predicted training level, establishing construct validity for the modified OSATS. Crowd scores were correlated with (r = 0.865, p < 0.0001) but consistently higher than expert scores for first, second, and third-year residents (p < 0.0001, paired t-test). Longer surgery duration negatively correlated with training level (r = -0.855, p < 0.0001) and expert score (r = -0.927, p < 0.0001). The longitudinal dataset reproduced cross-sectional study findings for crowd and expert comparisons. A regression equation transforming crowd score plus video length into expert score was derived from the cross-sectional dataset (r2 = 0.92) and demonstrated excellent predictive modeling when applied to the independent longitudinal dataset (r2 = 0.80). A group of student raters who had edited the cataract videos also graded them, producing scores that more closely approximated experts than the crowd. Crowdsourced rankings correlated with expert scores, but were not equivalent; crowd scores overestimated technical competency, especially for novice surgeons. A novel approach of adjusting crowd scores with surgery duration generated a more accurate predictive model for surgical skill. More studies are needed before crowdsourcing can be reliably used for assessing surgical proficiency.
1 April 2015 in Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science
Purpose: To determine if cataract surgery on eyes with age-related macular degeneration (AMD) confers as much functional visual improvement as on eyes without retinal pathology. Methods: This is a retrospective analysis of 4,924 cataract surgeries from the VA Ophthalmic Surgical Outcomes Data Project. We included cases of eyes with AMD which had both preoperative and postoperative NEI-VFQ-25 questionnaires submitted and compared their outcomes to controls without retinal pathology. We excluded patients with other retinal pathologies. The analyses compared changes in visual acuity and overall functional visual improvement and its subscales. Results: Preoperative and postoperative questionnaires were submitted by 58.3% of AMD and 63.8% of controls. Analysis of overall score showed that cataract surgery on eyes with AMD led to increased visual function (13.8± 2.4 NEI-VFQ units, P<0.0001); however, increases were significantly less when compared to controls (-6.4± 2.9 NEI-VFQ units, P<0.0001). Preoperative best corrected visual acuity (preBCVA) in AMD was predictive of postoperative visual function (r=-0.38, P<0.0001). In controls, postoperative visual function was only weakly associated with preBCVA (r=-0.075, P=0.0002). AMD patients with vision of 20/40 or better had overall outcomes similar to controls (-2.2± 4.7 NEI-VFQ units, P=0.37). Conclusions: Cataract surgery on eyes with AMD offers an increase in functional visual improvement; however, the amount of benefit is associated with the eye's preBCVA. For eyes with preBCVA ≥20/40, the improvement is similar to that of patients without retinal pathology. However, if preBCVA is <20/40, the amount of improvement was shown to be significantly less and decreased with decreasing preBCVA.
1 November 2015 in Cornea
Purpose: With new compounding pharmacy laws, the only economically feasible approach to using lissamine is through dye-impregnated strips. This research aims to determine the concentration of lissamine that can be obtained using a single commercially available lissamine strip. With the optimal vital staining requiring 1% concentration of lissamine, we sought to obtain this concentration using supplies in an ordinary ophthalmology clinic. Methods: A standard curve was generated using compounded lissamine green 1% solution. Serial dilutions were made with 3 different diluents and measured using a spectrophotometer at a wavelength of 633 μm. Combinations of the number of strips, amount of solvent, and absorption time were performed to obtain a 1% solution. Cost analyses were performed to select the most economical method. Results: Single lissamine strips wetted with any of the diluents produced 0.17% ± 0.05% (95% confidence interval) lissamine solution, a 5-fold weaker concentration than the optimal for vital staining. Combinations of 4 strips in 200 μL (4 drops) for 1 minute and 2 strips in 200 μL for 5 minutes were found to reach concentrations of 1%. Cost analysis showed that the 2 strip/4 drops/5 minutes method costs $0.67 and the 4 strips/4 drops/1 minute method $1.27. Conclusions: Use of a single lissamine strip leads to suboptimal concentrations for vital staining. With only the addition of disposable microcentrifuge tubes to the clinical setting, ophthalmologists can make 1% solutions of lissamine. This solution is both more economical and in compliance with both state and national compounding laws.
1 July 2014 in JAMA Ophthalmology
Case Report from JAMA Ophthalmology — Transient Blurred Vision in a Neurologically Decompensating Patient