Background: Accurate, reliable and efficient measures of pain-related presentations are essential to evaluate and improve pain care in the ED. Estimates of pain prevalence on arrival to the emergency department (ED) vary depending on the methods used. Artificial intelligence (AI) approaches are likely to be the future for identifying patients in pain from electronic health records (EHR). However, we need a robust method to identify these patients before this can occur. This study aims to identify patients presenting in pain to the ED using binary classification and to describe the population, treatment and outcomes. Methods: This study employs a cross-sectional design using retrospective data routinely collected in the EHR at a single ED. A random sample of 10 000 patients was selected for inclusion over three years. Triage nursing assessment underwent binary classification by three expert clinicians. The prevalence of pain on arrival is the primary outcome. Patients with pain were compared to those without pain on arrival regarding demographics, treatment and outcomes. Results: The prevalence of pain on arrival was 55.2% (95%CI 54.2% - 56.2%). Patients who presented in pain differed from those without pain in terms of age, country of birth, socioeconomic status, mode of arrival, urgency and discharge destination. The median time to first analgesic medication was 65min (IQR 38 – 114 min), and 45.6% (95% CI 44.3% - 46.9%) of patients arriving in pain received analgesic medication. Conclusions: The prevalence of pain on arrival compares well with previously reported figures using similar methods. Differences in the cohort presenting in pain compared to the population may represent differences in the prevalence or be an extension of previous bias seen in the documentation of pain. This work has set a rigorous methodology for identifying patients presenting with pain from the EHR. It will form the basis for future applications of AI to identify patients presenting in pain to the ED.
Pain is the most common symptom experienced when presenting to the emergency department (ED). Estimates indicate over half of all patients will present in pain. EDs typically focus on care process measures, such as time to first analgesic medication. Process-based metrics remove the patient from their own experience. Unfortunately, when patient-reported measures of pain care are used in the ED for quality improvement or research, they vary widely and often lack validation. Previous work has demonstrated that a modified version of the American Pain Society – Patient Outcome Questionnaire – Revised Edition (APS-POQ-R) may provide an ideal patient-reported outcome measure for the adult ED population. However, previous work has left validation incomplete. In this multi-site, multistage research, we demonstrate the construct, convergent and divergent validity and the internal consistency of a modified version of the APS-POQ-R in adult patients presenting to two large, inner-city EDs with moderate to severe acute pain. After three stages of psychometric testing in 646 patients, we present a nine-question, three construct patient-reported outcome measure for moderate to severe pain in the adult emergency department, now known as the American Pain Society – Patient Outcome Questionnaire – Revised for the ED (APS-POQ-RED). Perspective This article presents the psychometric properties of a revised version of the APS-POQ-R for use in the adult ED. This shortened, ED-specific patient-reported outcome measure (APS-POQ-RED) seeks to provide a standardised, validated measure of patient-reported outcomes of acute pain care in the ED for quality and research purposes.
Objective To estimate the prevalence of patients presenting in pain to an inner-city emergency department (ED), describing this population, their treatment, and the effect of the COVID-19 pandemic. Materials and Methods We applied a clinical text deep learning model to the free text nursing assessments to identify the prevalence of pain on arrival to the ED. Using interrupted time series analysis, we examined the prevalence over three years. We describe this population pre- and post-pandemic in terms of their demographics, arrival patterns and treatment. Results 55.16% (95%CI 54.95% - 55.36%) of all patients presenting to this ED had pain on arrival. There were significant differences in demographics, arrival and departure patterns between those patients with and without pain. The COVID-19 pandemic initially precipitated a decrease followed by a sharp, sustained rise in the prevalence of pain on arrival, altering the population arriving in pain and their treatment. Discussion The application of a clinical text deep learning model has successfully identified the prevalence of pain on arrival. The description of this population and their treatment forms the basis of intervention to improve care for patients presenting with pain. The combination of the clinical text deep learning model and interrupted time series analysis has identified the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on pain care in the ED. Conclusion A clinical text deep learning model has led to identifying the prevalence of pain on arrival and was able to identify the effect a major pandemic had on pain care in this ED.
Background: The treatment of pain in the emergency department (ED) has historically relied on pharmacological analgesia. However, little is known about the concurrent use of non-pharmacological analgesia. Aims/Objectives: This research explores the self-reported use and outcomes of non-pharmacological analgesia in adult ED patients with moderate to severe pain. Methods: This is a cross-sectional study in an adult ED of self-reported use of non-pharmacological pain management via a patient-reported outcome measure. The results are presented with descriptive statistics and multivariable modelling. Results: 45.8% (n=296) of all respondents used non-pharmacological interventions. The most used non-pharmacological interventions are hot packs (34.9%, n=103), distraction (22.3%, n=66), and cold packs (12.9%, n=38). In multivariate modelling, females, patients who did not receive pre-hospital analgesia, and daily average access block time all affected the use of non-pharmacological analgesia. Within a multivariable model, non-pharmacological analgesia increased the amount of pain relief achieved. Conclusion: Non-pharmacological analgesia use is affected by gender, treatment before the ED and ED workload. Nevertheless, clear benefits to the use of non-pharmacological analgesia were seen. Further work must be undertaken to encourage providers’ use of this modality and capture any additional benefits to the patient.