This study examines the relationship between efficiency, energy balance and related traits like milk yield, feed intake (DMI), body weight and body condition score (BCS). Data was derived in the project ‘Efficient Cow’ to develop efficiency traits for Austrian cattle breeding (6105 cows, 161 farms, one-year data collection). The following efficiency traits were considered: body weight efficiency as ratio between energy corrected milk (ECM) to metabolic body weight, feed efficiency (kg ECM per kg DMI) and energy efficiency expressed as ratio between energy in milk to energy intake. The higher the proportion of Red Holstein (RH) in Fleckvieh (FV), the more (efficiently) milk was produced, but also at the expenses of body fat reserves. The negative energy state of Holstein Friesian (HF) and the FV groups with highest RH proportion lasted approximately twice as long as of the least efficient Brown Swiss. All genotypes regained lost body tissue during whole lactation. The high yielding groups required a higher concentrate proportion in late lactation to regain body condition. In early lactation, high efficiency was accompanied by the loss of body weight and BCS. Body condition stagnated longer on the lowest level and was more conform to energy balance than body weight. In conclusion, high efficiency required an increasing partitioning of nutrients to milk yield inclusive mobilisation. Breeding for higher efficiency would exacerbate catabolic state including problems with health and fertility. This highlights the necessity of a broader definition of efficiency in cattle breeding involving parameters like BCS, health and fertility traits. HIGHLIGHTS
Respiration experiments with high-yielding dairy cows in Northern Ireland have shown higher energy maintenance requirements than those used in the requirements standards of, e.g. France, UK, USA and Germany. Therefore, the current net energy for lactation (NEL) system of Germany was tested by comparing measured NEL intake with calculated NEL requirements based on a comprehensive dataset from feeding trials conducted at nine research institutions in Germany, Austria and Switzerland. The relationship between NEL requirements and NEL intake is described by the equation: The equation indicates a systematic over-estimation of NEL requirements in the lower performance range and an under-estimation at higher energy intake levels. A multiple regression analysis was conducted by calculating metabolisable energy (ME) requirements [MJ/d] using metabolic body size (MBS) [kg0.75], milk energy performance (LE) [MJ/d] and body weight change (BWC) [kg/d]: These results indicate that the energy maintenance requirements are markedly higher than presumed in the feed evaluation systems commonly in use but confirm the results from Northern Ireland (0.600–0.660 MJ ME/kg0.75 MBS). ME efficiency for lactation is also higher (kL = 1/1.37 = 0.73) than that used in the systems and is also similar to the results of Northern Ireland with 0.64–0.69. The energy contribution of BWC derived by this equation is 12.1 MJ/kg (16.6 · 0.73) and distinctly lower than that of 21–25 MJ/kg presumed by the feeding standards, e.g. in Germany. Further, maintenance requirements were linked to milk yield (energy corrected milk (ECM) [kg/d]), as is practiced in the standard Australian energy system: These results demonstrate that maintenance energy requirements are partly dependent on milk yield. A differentiated analysis by stage of lactation showed that the regressions coefficients for MBS, LE and BWC change with lactation month; however, these findings apply especially to the first lactation months (i.e. in phases of intensive mobilisation).