24 January 2022 in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
High-elevation species are predicted to have larger elevational ranges compared with species of lower elevations. The reasoning is that temperature variability is greater at higher elevation, selecting for wider niche breadth and more plastic genotypes. We used macroevolutionary comparisons involving 90 Brassicaceae species of the central Alps to test for associations among median elevation of occurrence, elevational range size and thermal variability over space and time on the one hand, and their associations with performance breadth or trait plasticity on the other hand. Performance breadth and trait plasticity were estimated by raising replicate plants per species under three temperature treatments (mild, recurrent frost, recurrent heat). Against prediction, we found that mid-elevation species had the largest elevational ranges, and their ranges were associated with increased spatial thermal variability. Nevertheless, variability in the thermal regime was positively associated neither with niche breadth nor with plasticity. Evidence for adaptive constraints was limited to a trade-off between acclimation-based increases in frost and heat resistance, and phylogenetic niche conservatism for median elevation of occurrence and temporal thermal variability. Results suggest that large elevational range size is associated with divergent adaptation within species, but not with more niche breadth or trait plasticity. This article is part of the theme issue ‘Species’ ranges in the face of changing environments (part I)’.
20 July 2022 in Evolution
Species have restricted geographic distributions and the causes are still largely unknown. Temperature has long been associated with distribution limits, suggesting that there are ubiquitous constraints to the evolution of the climate niche. Here, we investigated the traits involved in such constraints by macroevolutionary comparisons involving 100 Brassicaceae species differing in elevational distribution. Plants were grown under three temperature treatments (regular frost, mild, regular heat) and phenotyped for phenological, morphological, and thermal resistance traits. Trait values were analyzed by assessing the effect of temperature and elevational distribution, by comparing models of evolutionary trajectories, and by correlative approaches to identify trade‐offs. Analyses pointed to size, leaf morphology, and growth under heat as among the most discriminating traits between low‐ and high‐elevation species, with high‐elevation species growing faster under the occurrence of regular heat bouts, at the cost of reduced size. Mixed models and evolutionary models supported adaptive divergence for these traits, and correlation analysis indicated their involvement in moderate trade‐offs. Finally, we found asymmetry in trait evolution, with evolvability across traits being 50% less constrained under regular frost. Overall, results suggest that trade‐offs between traits under adaptive divergence contribute to the disparate distribution of species along the elevational gradient.
20 May 2017 in Alpine Botany
7 January 2026 in New Phytologist
Summary: Temperature influences the distribution and performance of both plants and insect herbivores. Consequently, plant–herbivore interactions are likely to vary across thermal gradients, which could affect the evolution of plant defense. Furthermore, temperature fluctuations may elicit immediate changes in defense. To study the evolutionary and ecological aspects of plant antiherbivore defense depending on temperature, we conducted a transplant experiment on a mountain slope involving 30 Brassicaceae species varying in elevational distribution. Additionally, we carried out a climate‐chamber experiment on a subset of 12 species to assess the temperature dependence of constitutive and induced defenses. The transplant experiment revealed that species from higher elevations experienced less herbivory than those from lower elevations. The climate‐chamber experiment demonstrated that high‐elevation species mounted stronger induced defenses in physical properties of leaves and in phytochemical diversity. Plant responses to low temperature, compared to control temperature, were lower constitutive defense and increased defense induction limited to leaf toughness. By contrast, high temperature increased constitutive chemical defense and defense‐induced leaf toughness. Results suggest higher herbivory resistance in high‐elevation Brassicaceae species by the induced remodeling of chemical defense. Such defense indication may have been shaped by rare but hard‐to‐tolerate herbivory in the evolutionary past.
4 February 2022 in bioRxiv
Species have restricted geographic distributions and the causes are still largely unknown. Temperature has long been associated with distribution limits, suggesting that there are ubiquitous constraints to the evolution of the climate niche. Here we investigated the traits involved in such constraints by macroevolutionary comparisons involving around 100 Brassicaceae species differing in elevational distribution. Plants were grown under three temperature treatments (regular frost, mild, regular heat) and phenotyped for phenological, morphological and thermal resistance traits. Trait values were analysed by assessing the effect of temperature and elevational distribution, by comparing models of evolutionary trajectories, and by correlative approaches to identify trade-offs. Analyses pointed to size, leaf morphology and growth under heat as among the most discriminating traits between low- and high-elevation species, with high-elevation species growing faster under the occurrence of regular heat bouts, at the cost of much reduced size. Mixed models and evolutionary models supported adaptive divergence for these traits, and correlation analysis indicated their involvement in moderate trade-offs. Finally, we found asymmetry in trait evolution, with evolvability across traits being 50% less constrained under regular frost. Overall, results suggest that trade-offs between traits under adaptive divergence contribute to the disparate distribution of species along the elevational gradient.