Harmful blooms of cyanobacteria (cyanoHABs) are increasingly reported in remote and low-nutrient lakes, prompting a paradigm shift in our understanding of the drivers of cyanoHABs and a need to study factors beyond watershed nutrient inputs. In this study, we examined eight lakes within the Superior National Forest (Minnesota, USA) to characterize the role of lake stratification and oxygen depletion on nutrient and cyanobacteria abundance. Study lakes represented a gradient of mixing regimes, including well-mixed, dimictic, and polymictic. We found that mixing regime was a significant control on epilimnetic nutrient concentrations and cyanobacterial abundance, likely mediated through anoxic bottom waters and sediment phosphorus release. The frequent and intermittent lake turnover with anoxic bottom waters, which we term ‘anoximixis’, can help explain the rise of cyanoHABs in relatively pristine lakes with little watershed nutrient input. Climate change is predicted to alter stratification regimes which will promote more frequent anoximixis, sediment phosphorus release, and cyanoHAB formation; therefore, improving our understanding of the linkages between lake mixing and cyanoHABs will allow us to better characterize the effects of climate change in remote and low-nutrient input lakes.