This paper analyses nickel supply dynamics from the perspective of critical minerals for the energy transition. Using a long-run panel dataset (1942–2023) for a group of historically relevant strategic nickel producers, the study examines the extent to which nickel production and exports respond to price-based adjustment mechanisms or, alternatively, to structural supply-side factors. Based on dynamic fixed-effects models, the results show high persistence in both production and exports, as well as a central role of domestic productive capacity in explaining export behaviour. Although prices show some significant in certain specifications, their overall role remains secondary relative to structural supply-side factors. In addition, the evidence suggests that supply dynamics are conditioned by capacity constraints and strong path dependence. Robustness checks reinforce this interpretation: the role of productive capacity is maintained when its lagged value is used, while market price sensitivity proves specification-dependent and weakens when the nickel price is expressed in real terms. Taken together, the results carry important policy implications, suggesting that critical mineral supply security cannot rely exclusively on short-run price signals, but requires strategies aimed at managing structural supply-side constraints.