6 June 2022 in Public Management Review
This article explores the policy background of AI in ethical public services by applying the perspective of mutuality and trust to give a better understanding of the ethical evaluation of AI-enabled public services. The findings from Finnish government services emphasize that establishing governance rules arising from mutuality is not often viewed as a precursor to ethical evaluation, which was done post-facto with limited user engagement. We conclude that structured by a social mutuality framework, mutuality requires a systemic approach to ethics and active user engagement, which in turn requires an investment of time and cognitive attention by all agents involved.
28 April 2025 in Information Systems Frontiers
This study explores AI-enabled local public service provisioning, especially dilemmas of the mutual and meaningful development process. Theoretically, it builds on the current literature on AI implementation in the public sector and relates it to the theorisations of mutuality and meaningfulness. Empirically, it examines the experiences of public agents in a qualitative case study of chatbot development by the City of Oulu, Finland. The study concludes six factors that are constructed into three interconnected dilemma pairs to examine cross-cutting problematic decision-making scenarios and provide reconciliations through mutuality and meaningfulness.