10 February 2009 in Journal of Metamorphic Geology
24 January 2008 in Journal of Metamorphic Geology
17 January 2006 in Journal of Metamorphic Geology
1 February 2015 in Lithos
Recent work on mineral reactions and microstructures in metamorphic rocks has focused on forward modelling of phase equilibria and on their description through chemical potential relationships which control mass transfer in rocks. The available thermodynamic databases and computer programs for phase equilibria modelling have significantly improved the quantification and understanding of geodynamic processes. Therefore, our current methodological framework seems to be satisfactory. However, the quantification approaches in petrology focus on chemical processes with oversimplified mechanics. A review of the recent literature shows that mechanical effects in rocks may result in the development of pressure variations even on a hand specimen or grain scale. Such variations are critical for interpreting microstructural and mineral composition observations in rocks. Mechanical effects may influence element transport and mineral assemblage in rocks. Considering the interplay of mechanical properties and metamorphic reactions is therefore crucial for a correct interpretation of microstructural observations in metamorphic rocks as well as for quantification of processes. In this contribution, arguments against pressure variations are inspected and disproved. The published quantification procedure for systems with grain-scale pressure variations is reviewed. We demonstrate the equivalence of using Gibbs and Helmholtz energy in an isobaric system and go on to suggest that Gibbs free energy is more convenient for systems with pressure variations. Furthermore, we outline the implications of the new quantification approach for phase equilibria modelling as well as diffusion modelling. The appropriate modification of a macroscopic flux for a system with a pressure variation is derived and a consequence of using mass or molar units in diffusional fluxes is discussed. The impact of ignoring grain-scale pressure variations on geodynamic modelling and our understanding of the processes in the Earth’s interior is assessed. We show that if a pressure variation is overlooked, the error in depth estimates from crustal metamorphic rocks could be as large as the thickness of the crust
27 January 2014 in Journal of Metamorphic Geology
25 February 2020 in Solid Earth
Residual pressure can be preserved in mineral inclusions, e.g. quartz-in-garnet, after exhumation due to differential expansion between inclusion and host crystals. Raman spectroscopy has been applied to infer the residual pressure and provides information on the entrapment temperature and pressure conditions. However, the amount of residual pressure relaxation cannot be directly measured. An underestimation or overestimation of residual pressure may lead to significant errors between calculated and actual entrapment pressure. This study focuses on three mechanisms responsible for the residual pressure modification: (1) viscous creep; (2) plastic yield; (3) proximity of inclusion to the thin-section surface. Criteria are provided to quantify how much of the expected residual pressure is modified due to these three mechanisms. An analytical solution is introduced to demonstrate the effect of inclusion depth on the residual pressure field when the inclusion is close to the thin-section surface. It is shown that for a quartz-in-garnet system, the distance between the thin-section surface and inclusion centre needs to be at least 3 times the inclusion radius to avoid pressure release. In terms of viscous creep, representative case studies on a quartz-in-garnet system show that viscous relaxation may occur from temperatures as low as 600–700 ∘C depending on the particular pressure–temperature (P–T) path and various garnet compositions. For quartz entrapped along the prograde P–T path and subject to viscous relaxation at peak T above 600–700 ∘C, its residual pressure after exhumation may be higher than predicted from its true entrapment conditions. Moreover, such a viscous resetting effect may introduce apparent overstepping of garnet nucleation that is not related to reaction affinity.