We perform population synthesis simulations for Population III (Pop III) coalescing compact binary which merges within the age of the Universe. We found that the typical mass of Pop III binary black holes (BH–BHs) is ∼30 M⊙ so that the inspiral chirp signal of gravitational waves can be detected up to z = 0.28 by KAGRA, Adv. LIGO, Adv. Virgo and GEO network. Our simulations suggest that the detection rate of the coalescing Pop III BH–BHs is $$140(68)\ {\rm events\,yr^{-1} \,(SFR_p/(10^{-2.5}\,{\rm M}_{\odot }\,yr^{-1}\,Mpc^{-3}))\cdot Err_{sys}}$$ for the flat (Salpeter) initial mass function, respectively, where SFRp and Errsys are the peak value of the Pop III star formation rate and the possible systematic errors due to the assumptions in Pop III population synthesis, respectively. Errsys = 1 corresponds to conventional parameters for Pop I stars. From the observation of the chirp signal of the coalescing Pop III BH–BHs, we can determine both the mass and the redshift of the binary for the cosmological parameters determined by the Planck satellite. Our simulations suggest that the cumulative redshift distribution of the coalescing Pop III BH–BHs depends almost only on the cosmological parameters. We might be able to confirm the existence of Pop III massive stars of mass ∼30 M⊙ by the detections of gravitational waves if the merger rate of the Pop III massive BH–BHs dominates that of Pop I BH–BHs.
We present the merger rate density of Population III binary black holes (BHs) by means of a widely used binary population synthesis code BSE with extensions to very massive and extreme metal-poor stars. We consider not only low-mass BHs (lBHs: 5–50M⊙) but also high-mass BHs (hBHs: 130–200M⊙), where lBHs and hBHs are below and above the pair-instability mass gap (50–130M⊙), respectively. Population III BH–BHs can be categorized into three subpopulations: BH–BHs without hBHs (hBH0s: mtot ≲ 100M⊙), with one hBH (hBH1s: mtot ∼ 130–260M⊙), and with two hBHs (hBH2s: mtot ∼ 270–400M⊙), where mtot is the total mass of a BH–BH. Their merger rate densities at the current universe are ∼0.1 yr−1 Gpc−3 for hBH0s, and ∼0.01 yr−1 Gpc−3 for the sum of hBH1s and hBH2s, provided that the mass density of Population III stars is ∼1013M⊙ Gpc−3. These rates are modestly insensitive to initial conditions and single star models. The hBH1 and hBH2 mergers can dominate BH–BHs with hBHs discovered in the near future. They have low effective spins ≲0.2 in the current universe. The number ratio of hBH2s to hBH1s is high, ≳0.1. We also find that BHs in the mass gap (up to ∼85M⊙) merge. These merger rates can be reduced to nearly zero if Population III binaries are always wide (≳100R⊙), and if Population III stars always enter into chemically homogeneous evolution. The presence of close Population III binaries (∼10R⊙) is crucial for avoiding the worst scenario.
19 December 2015 in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Using our population synthesis code, we found that the typical chirp mass defined by (m1m2)3/5/(m1 + m2)1/5 of Population III (Pop III) binary black holes (BH–BHs) is ∼30 M⊙ with the total mass of ∼60 M⊙ so that the inspiral chirp signal as well as quasi-normal mode (QNM) of the merging black hole (BH) are interesting targets of KAGRA. The detection rate of the coalescing Pop III BH–BHs is ∼180 events yr− 1 (SFRp/(10−2.5 M⊙ yr−1 Mpc−3))([fb/(1 + fb)]/0.33)Errsys in our standard model, where SFRp, fb and Errsys are the peak value of the Pop III star formation rate, the binary fraction and the systematic error with Errsys = 1 for our standard model, respectively. To evaluate the robustness of chirp mass distribution and the range of Errsys, we examine the dependence of the results on the unknown parameters and the distribution functions in the population synthesis code. We found that the chirp mass has a peak at ∼30 M⊙ in most of parameters and distribution functions as well as Errsys ranges from 0.046 to 4. Therefore, the detection rate of the coalescing Pop III BH–BHs ranges about 8.3-720 events yr− 1(SFRp/(10− 2.5 M⊙ yr− 1 Mpc− 3))([fb/(1 + fb)]/0.33). The minimum rate corresponds to the worst model which we think unlikely so that unless (SFRp/(10− 2.5 M⊙ yr− 1 Mpc− 3))([fb/(1 + fb)]/0.33) ≪ 0.1, we expect the Pop III BH–BHs merger rate of at least one event per year by KAGRA. Nakano, Tanaka & Nakamura show that if signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) of QNM is larger than 35, we can confirm or refute the general relativity (GR) more than 5σ level. In our standard model, the detection rate of Pop III BH–BHs whose S/N is larger than 35 is 3.2 events yr− 1 (SFRp/(10− 2.5 M⊙ yr− 1 Mpc− 3))([fb/(1 + fb)]/0.33)Errsys. Thus, there is a good chance to check whether GR is correct or not in the strong gravity region.
4 December 2020 in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: Letters
In the case of zero-metal (Population III or Pop III) stars, we show that the total mass of binary black holes from binary Pop III star evolution can be ${\sim} 150 \, \mathrm{ M}_{\odot }$, which agrees with the mass of the binary black hole GW190521 recently discovered by LIGO/Virgo. The event rate of such binary black hole mergers is estimated as 0.13–0.66 (ρSFR/(6 × 105 M⊙ Mpc−3)) Errsys yr−1 Gpc−3, where ρSFR and Errsys are the cumulative comoving mass density of Pop III stars depending on star formation rate and the systematic errors depending on uncertainties in the Pop III binary parameters, respectively. The event rate in our fiducial model with ρSFR = 6 × 105 M⊙ Mpc−3 and Errsys = 1 is 0.13–0.66 yr−1 Gpc−3, which is consistent with the observed value of 0.02–0.43 yr−1 Gpc−3.
23 September 2020 in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
We performed Population III (Pop III) binary evolution using population synthesis simulations for seven different models. We found that Pop III binaries tend to be binary black holes (BBHs) with chirp mass Mchirp ∼ 30 M⊙ and they can merge in the present day, due to a long merger time. The merger rate densities of Pop III BBHs at z = 0 are in the range 3.34–21.2 |$\rm yr^{-1}\,Gpc^{-3}$| which is consistent with the Advanced Laser Interferometer Gravitational Wave Observatory (aLIGO)/Advanced Virgo (aVIRGO) result of 9.7–101 |$\rm yr^{-1}\,Gpc^{-3}$|. These Pop III binaries might contribute some portion of the massive BBH gravitational wave (GW) sources detected by aLIGO/aVIRGO. We also calculated the redshift dependence of Pop III BBH mergers. We found that Pop III low-spin BBHs tend to merge at low redshift, while Pop III high-spin BBHs merge at high redshift, which can be confirmed by future GW detectors such as Einstein Telescope (ET), Cosmic Explorer (CE), and DECi-hertz Interferometer Gravitational wave Observatory (DECIGO). These detectors can also check the redshift dependence of the BBH merger rate and spin distribution. Our results show that, except for one model, the mean effective spin 〈χeff〉 at z = 0 lies in the range 0.02–0.3, while at z = 10 it is 0.16–0.64. Therefore, massive stellar-mass BBH detection by GWs will be key for stellar evolution study in the early Universe.
21 May 2021 in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
GW190521 is a merger of two black holes (BHs), wherein at least one BH lies within the pair-instability (PI) mass gap, and it is difficult to form because of the effects of PI supernovae and pulsational PI (PPI). In this study, we examined the formation of GW190521-like BH-BHs under Population (Pop) III environments by binary population synthesis calculations. We reveal that convective overshooting in stellar evolution strongly affects the formation of GW190521-like BH-BHs. A model with a small overshoot parameter (similar to GENEC) can form GW190521-like BH-BHs. The derived merger rate is 4 × 10−2 yr−1 Gpc−3 at a redshift of ∼0.82, which is comparable to the merger rate of GW190521-like BH-BHs inferred by gravitational wave (GW) observations. In this model, a ∼90 M⊙ star collapses to form a ∼90 M⊙ BH by avoiding PPI and PISN even if it is a member of a binary star. This is because it expands up to 102 R⊙, and lose only little mass through binary evolution. However, a model with a large overshoot parameter (similar to Stern) cannot form GW190521-like BH-BHs at all. Thus, we cannot conclude that a Pop III binary system is the origin of GW190521 because determination of the overshoot parameter involves highly uncertain. If a Pop III binary system is the origin of GW190521, the merger rate of BH-BHs including a 100–135 M⊙ BH is substantially smaller than that of GW190521-like BH-BHs. This will be assessed by GW observations in the near future.