While abortion has been a contentious and salient political issue in the United States for decades, the debate around abortion has evolved in terms of the rhetorical frames employed by advocates on both sides. Using vignettes of statements made by hypothetical lawmakers, we evaluate responsiveness to some of these emergent frames. Specifically, we evaluate “pro-woman” framing employed by pro-life advocates, which positions abortion restrictions as being in the interests of women. The experiment also manipulates to whom the frame is attributed in two ways, the gender and the partisanship of the lawmaker. This 2 × 2 × 2 experiment explores the intersection of how abortion restrictions are framed, including the roles gender and partisanship in the persuasiveness of the frames. We find that voters are more receptive to the pro-woman frame compared to the classic fetal rights framing. Importantly, this holds even among supporters of abortion rights, casting substantial light on persuadable groups.
Based on legislation passed in 2021, we undertook a first-in-the-nation effort to survey elected and appointed officials in the state of New Jersey to collect basic demographic information. This survey ran into challenges that all surveys encounter, namely, how to reach respondents and how to get them to then complete the survey—especially with an elite population. An initial recruitment effort using official, and publicly available, email addresses yielded a low response rate, requiring us to revise our recruitment strategy. We settled on directly calling the offices of the New Jersey Assembly and Senate members to enlist the support for their Chiefs of Staff and legislative aides to assist us in getting the survey completed. Directly contacting the offices in this way more than doubled the response rates compared to email. Researchers should be mindful of the benefit of this recruitment mode in future efforts to survey legislators and be attentive to the additional costs and time associated with it.