Private and public sector structures and norms refine how emerging technology is used in practice. In healthcare, despite a proliferation of AI adoption, the organizational governance (i.e. institutional governance) surrounding its use and integration is often poorly understood. What the Health AI Partnership (HAIP) aims to do in this research is to better define the requirements for adequate organizational governance of AI systems in healthcare settings and support health system leaders to make more informed decisions around AI adoption. To work towards this understanding, we first identify how the standards for the AI adoption in healthcare may be designed to be used easily and efficiently. Then, we map out the precise decision points involved in the practical institutional adoption of AI technology within specific health systems. Practically, we achieve this through a multi-organizational collaboration with leaders from major health systems across the United States and key informants from related fields. Working with the consultancy IDEO.org, we were able to conduct usability-testing sessions with healthcare and AI ethics professionals. Usability analysis revealed a prototype structured around mock key decision points that align with how organizational leaders approach technology adoption. Concurrently, we conducted semi-structured interviews with 89 professionals in healthcare and other relevant fields. Using a modified grounded theory approach, we were able to identify 8 key decision points and comprehensive procedures throughout the AI adoption lifecycle. This is one of the most detailed qualitative analyses to date of the current governance structures and processes involved in AI adoption by health systems in the United States. We hope these findings can inform future efforts to build capabilities to promote the safe, effective, and responsible adoption of emerging technologies in healthcare.
The integration of Quality Management System (QMS) principles into the life cycle of development, deployment, and utilization of machine learning (ML) and artificial intelligence (AI) technologies within healthcare settings holds the potential to close the AI translation gap by establishing a robust framework that accelerates the safe, ethical, and effective delivery of AI/ML in day-to-day patient care. Healthcare organizations (HCOs) can implement these principles effectively by embracing an enterprise QMS analogous to those in regulated industries. By establishing a QMS explicitly tailored to health AI technologies, HCOs can comply with evolving regulations and minimize redundancy and rework while aligning their internal governance practices with their steadfast commitment to scientific rigor and medical excellence.
We report a case of a 45-year-old woman who presented a simultaneous foreign-body granuloma reaction to silicone in her face and to silica in the elbow and knee. The patient had received silicone injections in her face 7 years earlier and had suffered a motorcycle accident when she was young. Changes suggestive of silicone were observed in the biopsy obtained from the face, and silica was detected in the biopsy taken from the elbow, confirmed by polarized light and X-ray microanalysis. The presence of polarizable foreign matter in cutaneous epithelioid granulomas should alert to the diagnosis of sarcoidosis.
6 September 2024 in Mayo Clinic Proceedings: Digital Health
Health care organizations are building, deploying, and self-governing digital health technologies (DHTs), including artificial intelligence, at an increasing rate. This scope necessitates expertise and quality infrastructure to ensure that the technology impacting patient care is safe, effective, and ethical throughout its lifecycle. The objective of this article is to describe Mayo Clinic’s approach for embedding internal accountability as a case study for other health care institutions seeking modalities for responsible implementation of artificial intelligence–enabled DHTs. Mayo Clinic aims to enable and empower innovators by (1) building internal skills and expertise, (2) establishing a centralized review board, and (3) aligning development and deployment processes with regulations, standards, and best practices. In 2022, Mayo Clinic established the Software as a Medical Device Review Board (The Board), an independent body of physicians and domain experts to represent the organization in providing innovators regulatory and risk mitigation recommendations for DHTs. Hundreds of digital health product teams have since benefited from this function, intended to enable responsible innovation in alignment with regulation and state-of-the-art quality management practices. Other health care institutions can adopt similar internal accountability bodies using this framework. Opportunity remains to iterate on Mayo Clinic’s approach in alignment with advancing best practices and enhance representation on The Board as part of standard continuous improvement practices.
As artificial intelligence (AI) becomes further embedded in healthcare, healthcare delivery organizations (HDOs) must navigate a complex regulatory landscape. Health AI Partnership (HAIP) has created 31 best practice guides to inform the development, validation, and implementation of AI products. Here, we map the most common principles found in 8 key AI regulatory frameworks to HAIP recommended best practices to provide practical insights for compliance with expanding AI regulations.