The synthesis of the FeTi intermetallic compound via amorphization and mechanochemical synthesis from elemental Fe and Ti powders has been investigated. The results reveal that during mechanochemical synthesis from elemental iron and titanium powders (at 1820 rpm for 300 s of milling), a minor amount of the TiFe intermetallic compound is formed from the X-ray amorphous state due to local particle fusion. It was found that the TiFe intermetallic phase forms predominantly at the expense of the α-Ti phase, as the unit cell parameter a of the α-Fe phase remained unchanged at 0.2867 ± 5×10-4 nm. Meanwhile, the c/a ratio of α-Ti decreased from 1.5854 to 1.5479 with prolonged milling time due to lattice strain. It is shown that mechanochemical synthesis reduces the coherently diffracting domain (CDD, D) size of the α-Fe phase from 46 to 26 nm, and that of the α-Ti phase from 58 to 18 nm, driven by significant amorphization and the accumulation of defects at various length scales. Consequently, the dislocation density, calculated from X-ray diffraction (XRD) data, increased in the α-Ti phase from 10.3×1010 cm-2 to 92.6×1010 cm-2 (~9-fold), and in the α-Fe phase from 13.6×1010 cm-2 to 41.2×1010 cm⁻² (~4-fold) after 300 s of milling. It was established that homogenizing heat treatment at 800 °C increases the relative fraction of the TiFe phase from 2 % to 23 %. Nevertheless, complete synthesis of the TiFe phase was not achieved during mechanochemical synthesis due to the use of coarse iron powder, as diffraction peaks characteristic of α-Fe and α-Ti remain. Furthermore, homogenizing heat treatment at 800 °C leads to the formation of the Fe2Ti intermetallic compound, which is undesirable for hydrogenation. Apparently, the formation of regions with severe local iron concentration inhomogeneities promotes the formation of the Fe2Ti phase (reaching a relative fraction of 36 %) at higher heat treatment temperatures.