8 October 2018 in Behavior Research Methods
11 February 2019 in PLOS ONE
ADAnne-Katharina Deisenhofer
Anne-Katharina Deisenhofer
+3
In psychotherapy, movement synchrony seems to be associated with higher patient satisfaction and treatment outcome. However, it remains unclear whether movement synchrony rated by humans and movement synchrony identified by automated methods reflect the same construct. To address this issue, video sequences showing movement synchrony of patients and therapists (N = 10) or not (N = 10), were analyzed using motion energy analysis. Three different synchrony conditions with varying levels of complexity (naturally embedded, naturally isolated, and artificial) were generated for time series analysis with windowed cross-lagged correlation/ -regression (WCLC, WCLR). The concordance of ratings (human rating vs. automatic assessment) was computed for 600 different parameter configurations of the WCLC/WCLR to identify the parameter settings that measure movement synchrony best. A parameter configuration was rated as having a good identification rate if it yields high concordance with human-rated intervals (Cohen’s kappa) and a low amount of over-identified data points. Results indicate that 76 configurations had a good identification rate (IR) in the least complex condition (artificial). Two had an acceptable IR with regard to the naturally isolated condition. Concordance was low with regard to the most complex (naturally embedded) condition. A valid identification of movement synchrony strongly depends on parameter configuration and goes beyond the identification of synchrony by human raters. Differences between human-rated synchrony and nonverbal synchrony measured by algorithms are discussed.
1 December 2021 in Psychotherapy
Research indicates an effect of nonverbal synchrony on the therapeutic relationship and patients' symptom severity within psychotherapy. However, vocal synchrony research is still rare and inconsistent. This study investigates the relationship between vocal synchrony and outcome/attachment dimensions, controlling for therapeutic alliance and movement synchrony. Our sample consisted of 64 patients with social anxiety disorder. Symptom severity was assessed with the Liebowitz Social Anxiety Scale and the Inventory of Interpersonal Problems, whereas attachment was assessed with the Experiences in Close Relationships Questionnaire at the beginning and end of therapy. Therapeutic alliance was measured with the Helping Alliance Questionnaire II. We determined vocal synchrony of the median and range of the fundamental frequency (f 0) by correlating f 0 values of manually segmented speaker turns. Movement synchrony was assessed via motion energy and time-series analyses. Patient- and therapist-led synchrony was differentiated. Statistical analyses were performed using mixed effects linear models. Vocal synchrony had a negative impact on outcome. Higher vocal synchrony led to higher symptom severity (if the patient led synchrony, at the end of therapy) as well as attachment anxiety, avoidance, and interpersonal problems at the end of therapy. Predicting attachment anxiety, the effect of therapist-led vocal synchrony went beyond the effect of therapeutic alliance and movement synchrony. High vocal synchrony may arise due to a lack of autonomy in social anxiety disorder patients or might reflect attempts to repair alliance ruptures. The results indicate that vocal synchrony and movement synchrony have different effects on treatment outcome. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2021 APA, all rights reserved).
1 June 2021 in Journal of Psychotherapy Integration
ADAnne-Katharina Deisenhofer
Anne-Katharina Deisenhofer
+4
29 September 2023 in Methodology
In clinical research, the dependence of the results on the methods used is frequently discussed. In research on nonverbal synchrony, human ratings or automated methods do not lead to congruent results. Even when automated methods are used, the choice of the method and parameter settings are important to obtain congruent results. However, these are often insufficiently reported and do not meet the standard of transparency and reproducibility. This tutorial is aimed at researchers who are not familiar with the software Praat and R and shows in detail how to extract acoustic features like fundamental frequency or speech rate from video or audio files in conversations. Furthermore, it is presented how vocal synchrony indices can be calculated from these characteristics to represent how well two interaction partners vocally adapt to each other. All used scripts as well as a minimal example, can be found on the Open Science Framework and Github.