The quantity and orientation of steel fibers in a structural UHPC element will impact its ability to carry and distribute tensile stresses. UHPC is typically placed as a highly flowable material. As a result, the fibers in UHPC tend to align along the direction of flow, and in undesirable conditions may segregate. Both of these properties can significantly influence fiber alignment and thereby impact the local tensile behavior of the material. Quality assurance and quality control (QA/QC) methods for characterizing the quantity and alignment of fibers in UHPC elements are needed for assessing the impact of the flow properties and placement methods on the structural performance of a UHPC element. Accordingly, two techniques have been independently developed to characterize fiber distribution and alignment in UHPC cores extracted from structural members: (1) three-dimensional imaging of concrete samples by x-ray microtomography and (2) twodimensional imaging of individual cut surfaces. This paper presents a collaborative research effort in which the fiber quantity and fiber orientation of ten samples of UHPC, extracted from four different full-scale UHPC members, were characterized using both the three-dimensional and twodimensional imaging techniques. Parallel analyses were performed to quantify the total fiber content and "axial alignment factors" for each sample using each method, and the results were compared. The results indicate that while three-dimensional imaging by x-ray microtomography of fiber alignment provides a comprehensive assessment of fiber alignment, two-dimensional analysis of cut planes can provide a reasonable estimate for use as a QA/QC method or as a tool to investigate or explain UHPC performance, provided that results are appropriately normalized.