With increased natural disasters, disaster preparedness for those living with a disability is paramount. Support workers of people living with a disability are directly implicated in their disaster preparedness, playing a critical role in evacuation and emergency responses, yet little is understood about their preparedness. This mixed-methods study explored attitudes, experiences, and knowledge of 137 support workers working with clients with a diverse range of disability(ies) and support needs. Qualitative data analysis resulted in the identification of three themes: the mental health and resiliency of clients, highlighting how disasters may exacerbate mental health concerns, navigating the uncontrollable, that is, the psychological impacts of losing control in disasters, with implications for client and support worker well-being, and the cognitive load of disaster management, which for support workers comes from managing access to supplies and medications. Quantitative findings revealed that many support workers were concerned about a disaster but felt some confidence in their ability to respond to one, despite most not being trained in disaster management. More disaster preparedness training was related to lower confidence levels in responding to a disaster event, suggesting that current training protocols may not be effective or, alternatively, that more understanding of what is involved in disaster responding may result in a more realistic, but less confident, appraisal of disaster preparedness. Current frameworks place the responsibility of planning on the individual, yet effective disaster responses require a whole-of-community approach to ensure the safety of people living with disability and support workers.