15 September 2023 in Journal of Petrology
Serpentinites play an important role in the delivery of water into subduction zones. In addition, serpentinites also contain ferric Fe and can transport significant redox potential. We present high-pressure and high-temperature experiments and Mössbauer spectroscopy measurements on natural lizardite and antigorite samples equilibrated at various oxygen fugacities in order to quantify the relationship between the oxygen fugacity f(O2) and the Fe3+/Fetot ratio in these two phases. In antigorite Fe3+ partitions into the octahedral site and is charge-balanced by tetrahedral Al. In lizardite tetrahedral Fe3+ is observed only at low temperature as well as under high f(O2), whereas Fe3+ prefers the octahedral site at temperatures exceeding 500 °C and at 3 to 5 GPa. Although metastable, lizardite remains in redox equilibrium in our experiments at conditions above the lizardite to antigorite phase transformation at 300 °C and demonstrates a similar stability to antigorite. The Al concentration of lizardite is found to be temperature dependent and it was possible to reequilibrate the Fe3+/Fetot ratio of lizardite from 0.1 to 0.9 by using redox buffers such as Fe metal, graphite, graphite-calcite, Re-ReO2 and Ru-RuO2. Our experiments on antigorite demonstrate that antigorite does not adjust its Al concentration on experimental time scales. Since Fe3+ is charge-balanced by Al, it was also not possible to manipulate the Fe3+/Fetot ratio of antigorite. The coexisting phases, however, show chemical equilibration with this antigorite composition. We have retrieved the standard Gibbs energy for Fe3+- and Al-endmembers of antigorite and lizardite and calculated the metamorphic evolution of subducting serpentinites. The lizardite to antigorite transformation does not cause a decrease in the bulk Fe3+/Fetot ratio under f(O2) buffered conditions, in contrast to observations from some natural settings, but does result in the formation of additional magnetite due to antigorite having a lower Fe3+/Fetot ratio than lizardite at equilibrium. If the f(O2) of antigorite serpentinite is buffered during subduction, such as due to the presence of graphite and carbonate, the bulk Fe3+/Fetot ratio decreases progressively. On the other hand, in a closed system where the bulk serpentinite Fe3+/Fetot ratio remains constant, the f(O2) increases during subduction. In this scenario the f(O2) of an antigorite serpentinite with a typical Fe3+/Fetot ratio of 0.4 increases from the fayalite-magnetite-quartz to the hematite-magnetite f(O2) buffer during dehydration. These f(O2) results confirm earlier inferences that fluids produced by antigorite dehydration may not contain sufficient oxidised sulfur species to oxidise the mantle wedge. Sufficiently high levels of f(O2) to mobilise oxidised sulfur species may be reached upon antigorite dehydration, however, if closed system behaviour maintains a high bulk redox potential across the lizardite to antigorite phase transformation. Alternatively, oxidation of the mantle wedge might be achieved by oxidizing agents from sources in subducted oceanic crust and sediments.
2 March 2023 in Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology
To investigate the effect of carbon-bearing phases on the release of fluids in subducted serpentinites, we performed high-pressure multi-anvil experiments on representative ophicarbonate assemblages over a pressure range from 2.5 GPa to 5 GPa and from 450 °C to 900 °C, across the antigorite-out reaction. Parallel experiments were performed on carbonate-free serpentinites. In all experiments, we monitored and/or controlled the oxygen fugacity. The addition of 20 wt. % CaCO3 to a serpentinite assemblage at 2.5 GPa is found to decrease the onset of the serpentine dehydration by over 100 °C, in comparison to carbonate-free assemblages. Similarly, the final disappearance of serpentine is also affected by the presence of CaCO3. For a bulk CaCO3 content of 20 wt. %, this causes a decrease in maximum stability of antigorite by 50 °C. For a bulk CaCO3 content exceeding 25 wt. %, this difference can be as high as 100 °C in warm and 150 °C in cold subduction zones, causing antigorite to be completely dehydrated at 500 °C. This results from the reaction of CaCO3 with serpentine to form clinopyroxene and Mg-rich carbonates. This reaction, however, causes no discernible decrease in the proportion of carbonate, indicating that the amount of released carbon is insignificant. Whilst CaCO3, therefore, influences serpentine stability, there is no significant effect of hydrous phases on the carbonate stability. On the other hand, a MgCO3-bearing system shows no significant effects on the serpentinite stability field. Further experiments and oxygen fugacity calculations indicate that graphite is not stable in typical magnetite-bearing serpentinites. The reduction of carbonates to graphite would require oxygen fugacities that are 1–2 log units below those of magnetite-bearing serpentinites. This confirms earlier studies and indicates that reduction of carbonates can only occur through the infiltration of external H2-rich fluids.
21 September 2023 in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
We have performed in situ time‐of‐flight neutron diffraction experiments to examine the uptake of deuterium in iron monosulfide at pressures up to 11.4 GPa and temperatures to 1300 K. A D2 fluid was formed in the experiments through the decomposition of ND3BD3, resulting in an oxygen fugacity of approximately 1.2 log units below the iron‐wüstite buffer. Deuterium positions and site occupancies were determined in FeS V, using Rietveld refinements of the powder neutron diffraction patterns. Our structural model indicates that two normally unoccupied sites in the P63/mmc FeS V structure, at Wyckoff positions 6h and 4f, are partially occupied by D atoms, with the latter being more dominant. The deuterium content Dx in FeSDX increases with both pressure and temperature over the experimental conditions explored, from 0.126 (14) at 2.3 GPa and 787 K to 1.20 (16) at 9.7 GPa and 1300 K. The unit‐cell volume expansion per deuterium atom is 1.53 ± 0.16 Å3 at 6.9 GPa and 960 K, which is smaller than that determined for metallic iron phases at similar conditions. The variation in unit‐cell volume indicates that most deuterium is lost from FeS V upon temperature quenching at high‐pressures. By fitting the obtained FeS V deuterium site occupancies to a thermodynamic model, estimates for the hydrogen contents of iron monosulfide at conditions and oxygen fugacities consistent with the base of the cratonic lithosphere can be made. This results in values in the range of 1,700–2,700 ppm, which contribute to approximately 2–3 ppm hydrogen in the bulk mantle.
17 April 2025 in Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology
Aqueous fluids released by metamorphic dehydration of serpentinites are a key component for seismicity, creep, and geochemical cycling in subduction zones. How these fluids drain and migrate towards the mantle wedge has yet to be fully understood. Here we address the influence of pre-existing structural and mineralogical heterogeneities in serpentinites on dehydration and fluid migration at forearc conditions. We partially dehydrated natural serpentinite containing brucite veins in a piston-cylinder apparatus with a temperature gradient across the conditions of the brucite + antigorite = olivine + fluid reaction (485–520 °C; 1.5 GPa). Micro-tomography, electron microscopy and microstructural analysis of the experimental results, coupled with thermodynamic modelling, show that temperature, mineralogical heterogeneity and variable ingress of external H2 controlled the dehydration extent. Experimentally formed olivine indicates a topotactic relationship between [100]Ol and [0001]Brc, although the resultant fabric is overall random because brucite was randomly oriented. Olivine forms mono-mineralic aggregates along the walls of brucite veins, displaying very high porosity (up to 32%) and permeability (10–13–10–14 m2). Tracing the pre-existing brucite vein network, these aggregates can form a transient network of interconnected, highly permeable fluid channels that allows drainage and may enhance open-system exchange with neighboring lithologies. Infiltration of reduced external fluids can trigger redox dehydration of magnetite + antigorite to Fe-rich olivine, which renews porosity and propagates focused fluid flow. The distribution of brucite and magnetite, especially as vein networks, therefore has a first-order control on how focused fluid drainage and flow paths develop during subduction of serpentinites.
8 September 2022 in Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems
A new method to determine fluid flux at high pressures and temperatures has been developed and used to study serpentinites at subduction zone conditions. Drill cores of a natural antigorite‐serpentinite with a strong foliation were used in multi‐anvil experiments in the range of 2–5 GPa and 450–800°C. Fluids released upon dehydration are fixed by the formation of brucite in an adjacent fluid sink. The amount and distribution of brucite serves as a proxy for fluid flow. In our specific setup the sample reacted with the surrounding fluid sink to form an additional layer of olivine, which has the potential to limit fluid flux within our experiments. For conditions prior to serpentine dehydration we used Al(OH)3 as fluid source. Fluid in this experiment did not migrate through the serpentinite, indicating that serpentine has a low diffusivity. The experiments also show that small deviatoric stresses have an influence on the fluid flux and can cause an anisotropic fluid flux. Comparison between the time scales of the determined fluid flux with fluid production rates indicates fluid pressure buildup during dehydration reactions. Adjacent less permeable layers can inhibit fluid flux and cause fluid pressure buildup even at conditions when an interconnected pore space formed.
22 December 2024 in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
The seismic potential of faults depends on the local mineralogy and can change upon mineral reactions. We conducted friction experiments on serpentinite, carbonate and carbonated serpentinite fault gouges at temperatures from 400°C to 630°C, under 100 MPa effective normal stress and fluid saturated conditions. Pure serpentinite fault gouges exhibited unstable slip with significant strain‐hardening. Carbonate‐bearing serpentinite fault gouges showed stable sliding at temperatures <500°C, but displayed unstable stick‐slip behavior and strong strain weakening at temperatures ≥500°C. Microstructural analyses revealed localization and the formation of olivine and pyroxene from devolatilization reactions at temperatures ≥500°C. The degree of devolatilization increased near major slip planes and was enhanced by higher temperature and carbonate content, as shown by three‐dimensional micro‐computer tomography analyses. Nano‐scale transmission electron microscopy analyses revealed the absence of hydrous and carbonate phases along major slip planes. We attribute the strong weakening and unstable slip behavior in carbonated serpentinite fault gouges to the formation of nano‐sized anhydrous phases of olivine and pyroxene along the slip plane. Our results indicate that serpentinized fault zones may experience seismic event nucleation at temperatures approaching the thermodynamic stability limit of serpentine. This suggests that the absence of seismic events cannot exclusively be attributed to serpentinization. The formation of carbonates, through replacive and additive carbonation, can explain aseismic deformation in transform faults, but at elevated temperatures, devolatilization reactions in carbonated serpentinites cause strong localization and strain weakening, accompanied by laboratory seismicity.