The 2015 ACMG/AMP standards and guidelines for interpretation of sequence variants are widely used by laboratories, including for variant curation of the hereditary hemorrhagic telangiectasia (HHT) genes. However, the need for gene- and disease-specific modifications and specifications of these general guidelines to optimize and standardize variant classification was recognized at the time of publication. With this goal, the ClinGen HHT variant curation expert panel was formed. Here, we describe our recommended HHT-specific variant classification criteria and the outcomes from pilot testing of 30 variants of the ENG and ACVRL1 genes. Eight of the original ACMG/AMP rules were determined to not be applicable for ENG- or ACVRL1-related HHT or were previously recommended by ClinGen for removal, two rules were unmodified, and the remaining 18 rules were modified according to HHT specifications or previous ClinGen general recommendations. This study demonstrates the importance of HHT-specific criteria in the optimization and standardization of HHT variant classification and conflicting classification resolution.
27 May 2022 in Molecular Genetics & Genomic Medicine
Background: Hereditary hemorrhagic telangiectasia (HHT) is an autosomal dominant vascular disorder, affecting 1:5000 individuals worldwide. All the genes associated to the disease (ENG, ACVRL1, SMAD4, GDF2) belong to the TGF‐β/BMPs signaling pathway.We found 19 HHT unrelated families, coming from a Northern Italy region and sharing the ACVRL1 in‐frame deletion c.289_294del (p.H97_N98).Methods: To test the hypothesis of a founder effect, we analyzed 88 subjects from 19 families (66 variant carriers, showing clinical signs of HHT, and 22 non‐carriers, unaffected) using eight microsatellite markers within 3.7 Mb around the ACVRL1 locus. After the haplotype reconstruction, age estimation of the variant was carried out.Results: We observed a common disease haplotype in 16/19 families, while three families showed evidence of recombination around the ACVRL1 locus. The subsequent age estimation analyses suggested that the mutation occurred about 8 generations ago, corresponding to about 200 years ago. We also present novel in silico and modeling data supporting the variant pathogenicity: the deletion alters the protein stability and removes the unique extracellular glycosylation site.Conclusion: We have demonstrated, for the first time, a “founder effect” for a HHT pathogenic variant in Italy.
BACKGROUND: Hereditary hemorrhagic telangiectasia (HHT) is a genetic disorder caused by pathogenic variants in the endothelial TGFβ/BMP pathway, crucial for the vascular arterial-venous differentiation. Vascular defects result in fragile and malformed vessels. The precise mechanisms driving vascular network failure remain incompletely understood, complicating the design of targeted therapies. METHODS: Nasal telangiectasias from HHT patients carrying variants in ACVRL1 or ENG were used to perform scRNA-seq (2 ACVRL1- and 1 ENG-patient) and spatial transcriptomics (1 ACVRL1 and 1 ENG) to uncover endothelial cells (EC) populations. Vascular characteristics within biopsies were evaluated using transmission electron microscopy (TEM) (1 ACVRL1 and 1 ENG) and histological analyses (23 ACVRL1 and 7 ENG), with particular attention to regions exhibiting varying degrees of damage. RESULTS: Comparing our HHT tissues with healthy donor from the literature, we identified cellular heterogeneity within EC populations, revealing two distinct venous clusters: a stable, quiescent population (Mature Vein) and an activated, pro-inflammatory population (HHT Vein). The coexistence of these two clusters suggests cellular diversity within the biopsy, further validated by TEM and histology, revealing a juxtaposition of well-organized collagen and cellular architecture with severely disrupted, fibrotic regions. Moreover, cellular crosstalk analyses allowed us to identify critical ligands in ECs that interact with fibroblasts and mural cells. In particular, we found Midkine (MDK) lost in HHT Vein ECs with further validation in vitro, suggesting its potential role in cellular stability. Furthermore, spatial transcriptomics allowed to further uncover pathologic phenotypes in cells neighboring HHT Vein ECs. CONCLUSIONS: HHT biopsies exhibit localized inflamed and fibrotic vascular areas with the presence of different transcriptional sub-populations of EC. Within the same tissue, stable and activated ECs can be distinguished. The pathologic-like EC cluster, present exclusively in the HHT samples, may contribute to vascular leakage through the loss of important ligands involved in cellular communication.