Significance: Decisions are guided by available information and strategies that link information to action. Following a bad outcome, two potential sources of error—flawed strategy and poor information—must be distinguished to improve future performance. In a direction discrimination task where subjects decide by accumulating sensory evidence to a bound, we show that humans disambiguate sources of error by integrating expected accuracy and outcome over multiple choices. The strategy switches when the integral reaches a threshold. A hierarchy of decision processes in which lower levels integrate sensory evidence over short timescales, and higher levels interact with lower levels over longer timescales, quantitatively explains the behavior. Expected accuracy links these two levels and enables adaptive changes of decision strategy.