Food computing, a newly emerging topic, is closely linked to human life through computational methodologies. Meal recommendation, a food-related study about human health, aims to provide users a meal with courses constrained from specific categories (e.g., appetizers, main dishes) that can be enjoyed as a service. Historical interaction data, important user information, is often used by existing models to learn user preferences. However, if a user’s preferences favor less healthy meals, the model will follow that preference and make similar recommendations, potentially negatively impacting the user’s long-term health. This emphasizes the necessity for health-oriented and responsible meal recommendation systems. In this article, we propose a healthiness-aware and category-wise meal recommendation model called CateRec, which boosts healthiness exposure by using nutritional standards as knowledge to guide the model training. Two fundamental questions are raised and answered: (1) How can the healthiness of meals be evaluated? Two well-known nutritional standards from the World Health Organization and the United Kingdom Food Standards Agency are used to calculate the healthiness score of the meal. (2) How can the model training be guided in a health-oriented manner? We construct category-wise personalization partial rankings and category-wise healthiness partial rankings, and theoretically analyze that they meet the necessary properties and assumptions required to be trained by the maximum posterior estimator under Bayesian probability. The data analysis confirms the existence of user preferences leaning towards less healthy meals in two public datasets. A comprehensive experiment demonstrates that our CateRec effectively boosts healthiness exposure in terms of mean healthiness score and ranking exposure while being comparable to the state-of-the-art model in terms of recommendation accuracy.
Meal recommendation, as a typical health-related recommendation task, contains complex relationships between users, courses, and meals. Among them, meal-course affiliation associates user-meal and user-course interactions. However, an extensive literature review demonstrates that there is a lack of publicly available meal recommendation datasets including meal-course affiliation. Meal recommendation research has been constrained in exploring the impact of cooperation between two levels of interaction on personalization and healthiness. To pave the way for meal recommendation research, we introduce a new benchmark dataset called MealRec^+. Due to constraints related to user health privacy and meal scenario characteristics, the collection of data that includes both meal-course affiliation and two levels of interactions is impeded. Therefore, a simulation method is adopted to derive meal-course affiliation and user-meal interaction from the user's dining sessions simulated based on user-course interaction data. Then, two well-known nutritional standards are used to calculate the healthiness scores of meals. Moreover, we experiment with several baseline models, including separate and cooperative interaction learning methods. Our experiment demonstrates that cooperating the two levels of interaction in appropriate ways is beneficial for meal recommendations. The dataset is available on GitHub (https://github.com/WUT-IDEA/MealRecPlus).
In recent years, bundle recommendation systems have gained significant attention in both academia and industry due to their ability to enhance user experience and increase sales by recommending a set of items as a bundle rather than individual items. This survey provides a comprehensive review on bundle recommendation, beginning by a taxonomy for exploring product bundling. We classify it into two categories based on bundling strategy from various application domains, i.e., discriminative and generative bundle recommendation. Then we formulate the corresponding tasks of the two categories and systematically review their methods: 1) representation learning from bundle and item levels and interaction modeling for discriminative bundle recommendation; 2) representation learning from item level and bundle generation for generative bundle recommendation. Subsequently, we survey the resources of bundle recommendation including datasets and evaluation metrics, and conduct reproducibility experiments on mainstream models. Lastly, we discuss the main challenges and highlight the promising future directions in the field of bundle recommendation, aiming to serve as a useful resource for researchers and practitioners. Our code and datasets are publicly available at https://github.com/WUT-IDEA/bundle-recommendation-survey.
Recommendation systems are important in web3.0 as a technology to achieve high-quality interaction between people and the web. Meal recommender system, as an application of bundle recommendation, aims to provide courses from specific categories (e.g., appetizer, main dish) that are enjoyed as a meal for a user. Common methods include collaborative filtering, attention-based and graph-based ones, etc. User-meal interaction learning is the core of a meal recommendation and its key feature is category-constrained. However, there is no work to compare and study different types of methods. Moreover, existing work does not make full use of category information in the meal recommendation. In this paper, we conduct a reproducibility study about user-meal interaction learning for meal recommendation. We reproduce seven state-of-the-art meal and general bundle recommendation models and re-implement two models with considering category information. Extensive experiments are conducted on two datasets with different user-meal interaction densities to explore the impact of data density on different types of user-meal interaction learning, and investigate the effectiveness of different category-wise implementations. The experimental results are instructive and beneficial to the development and application of meal recommendation research.
Meal recommendation, as a typical health-related recommendation task, contains complex relationships between users, courses, and meals. Among them, meal-course affiliation associates user-meal and user-course interactions. However, an extensive literature review demonstrates that there is a lack of publicly available meal recommendation datasets including meal-course affiliation. Meal recommendation research has been constrained in exploring the impact of cooperation between two levels of interaction on personalization and healthiness. To pave the way for meal recommendation research, we introduce a new benchmark dataset called MealRec$^+$. Due to constraints related to user health privacy and meal scenario characteristics, the collection of data that includes both meal-course affiliation and two levels of interactions is impeded. Therefore, a simulation method is adopted to derive meal-course affiliation and user-meal interaction from the user's dining sessions simulated based on user-course interaction data. Then, two well-known nutritional standards are used to calculate the healthiness scores of meals. Moreover, we experiment with several baseline models, including separate and cooperative interaction learning methods. Our experiment demonstrates that cooperating the two levels of interaction in appropriate ways is beneficial for meal recommendations. Furthermore, in response to the less healthy recommendation phenomenon found in the experiment, we explore methods to enhance the healthiness of meal recommendations. The dataset is available on GitHub (https://github.com/WUT-IDEA/MealRecPlus).