Achieving net-zero climate targets requires some level of carbon dioxide removal. Current assessments focus on tonnes of CO2 removed, without specifying what form these removals will take. Here, we show that countries’ climate pledges require approximately 1 (0.9–1.1) billion ha of land for removals. For over 40% of this area, the pledges envisage the conversion of existing land uses to forests, while the remaining area restores existing ecosystems and land uses. We analyse how this demand for land is distributed geographically and over time. The results are concerning, both in terms of the aggregate area of land, but also the rate and extent of land use change. Our findings demonstrate a gap between governments’ expected reliance on land and the role that land can realistically play in climate mitigation. This adds another layer to the observed shortcomings of national climate pledges and indicates a need for more transparency around the role of land in national climate mitigation plans.
26 September 2024 in Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space
The voluntary carbon market (VCM) faces a legitimacy crisis amid accusations of greenwashing, just as companies worldwide increasingly rely on it to achieve their net-zero targets. To address the criticisms, digital technologies to improve the monitoring, reporting and verification (MRV) process of nature-based carbon projects are envisioned to provide greater transparency and thus restore the legitimacy of the market. This study analyses narratives and visions developing around digital MRV, building on observations at industry events and public communication from digital MRV enterprises. Drawing on critical nature-society scholarship and literatures on green capitalism, I argue that digital MRV enables a vision of planetary improvement through large-scale nature restoration. Yet, as the technologies are largely used to produce a larger supply of more trust-worthy carbon credits, I suggest that digital MRV mainly serves to solve two issues in the VCM, namely that of buyers facing reputational risks and expected supply constraints. As such, I argue that digital MRV by providing non-disruptive disruption through making nature legible to market logics serves as a technical fix to the VCM’s legitimacy crisis. Rather than transforming carbon markets and nature restoration, digital technologies enable and relegitimise ongoing carbon offsetting practices and in turn capital accumulation by incumbent stakeholders.